• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

MAC Guys, your time to shine!!!

Tan

MB Enthusiast
SUPPORTER
Joined
Oct 2, 2002
Messages
2,901
Location
Woodford Green
Car
W140 S-Class, Porsche Cayenne and Porsche Boxster
Hi

I have been offered the choice between a MAC Book Pro 13" (2.53Ghz and 4GB RAM) or a Mac Book Air (1.8GHz and 2Gb RAM)?

Which is better?

I won't be carrying the laptop around alot, but do want the 13" version for when I do.

Regards

Tan
 
Agreed - the Air is a piece of art but to be productive get the Pro.

Then give me the Air :D
 
At the moment all I will use it for is Internet, Office and a little bit of home user photo editing.
 
Hi

I have been offered the choice between a MAC Book Pro 13" (2.53Ghz and 4GB RAM) or a Mac Book Air (1.8GHz and 2Gb RAM)?

Which is better?

Let me join the chorus:

Macbook Pro
 
I have the MacBook Pro .. the Air is too delicate, and it does not have a drive.

The MBP isn't not heavy, but a wonderful piece of kit.

some of my quotes from previous threads:

Aug 09
"I bought a Macbook Pro ... after a saga of Sony cancelling my order, and the first MBP being lost by UPS.

Been using the MBP for 2 days. Love it. Easy to use, intuitive.

What I like most so far is the touch pad .. so versatile, and you do so many things, and so brilliant. Comparing a MBP touch pad to a Windows laptop touch pad is like flying in first class as opposed to cargo.

I spent years avoiding Macs. They are amazing. For non IT specialists like me, they should be compulsory.

Love it. Amazing.

LIGHT YEARS ahead of Vista.

And stable too. "


Nov 09
"have had my MBP for a few months now.

am completely converted to Apple

Love it

especially:

1. the touch pad, the 1, 2, 3 and 4 finger movements are fabulous
2. the fast start up
3. the fast shut down
4. time machine -- easy harddisk backup
5. battery life -- amazing, about 4 hours
6. backlit keys
7. feel .. a lovely thing to behold

not so great:

1. some java websites don't work so well -- these are probably optimised for Windows

2. that's it"
 
I have the air. If you are using it for the things you listed, and have access to other pcs etc when required, i would go for it (with the processor and ram upgrades where poss).

Actually Tan, dont you work in IT? The Air can piggyback other pcs drives so that is never an issue, and the plug in drive is great for when needed.

The whole point of a lap top to me is carrying it around. The air is great for this and looking v cool....
 
Rich, yes I do work in IT on the sales side now and most of our techies are very anti MAC.

I think the added strength of the MAC book Pro will come in handy with a 3 month old baby around.
 
Macbook Pro, I solely work with Mac, never touch a PC, Mac all the way for me, you have more flexibility with the pro than air, air just geared towards city slickers, not worth the money in comparison to the Pro.
 
...most of our techies are very anti MAC.

...likely because there's less need for technical support required for Macintosh compared to PC's - and therefore less need for as many technical support personnel.

Oh, and go Pro!
 
MAC BOOK PRO. All the way.. 2 nd best thing I ever bought! iPhone is the best!
 
Rich, yes I do work in IT on the sales side now and most of our techies are very anti MAC. .
:D

That's probably 'cos most of your techies have no idea how to use one and really only know anything about PCs....that's certainly the case where I work. It's a very easy defence mechanism. Once they actually spend some time with one however....

Here's some edited text from a recent email exchange between me and one of the key IT support guys at our place. This is a guy that supports several thousand PC and Blackberry users, and hated Macs....


From: X
Sent: 31 August 2009 11:52
To: Y
Subject: Re: Quick Question

Thanks!

I never knew you were a secret MacUser!

From: Y
Sent: 31 August 2009 13:43
To: X
Subject: Re: Re: Quick Question

Only in the lasdt 2 months. Bought a imac 24”
Never going back
Loving it.
 
As per the others , MBP is a much more capable piece of kit , if slightly heavier and less portable .

Battery life on Air might be a little longer due to having less componentry to power - only worth considering if you are likely to have lengthy sessions away from a power source .

I keep an inverter in my car for times when I have to do photo processing or video editing at a job and email files out to media .
 
:D

That's probably 'cos most of your techies have no idea how to use one and really only know anything about PCs....that's certainly the case where I work. It's a very easy defence mechanism. Once they actually spend some time with one however....

I used to be a techie, and now am a consultant. While I'm not "anti-mac" I don't think they are as good as most people make them out to be. The hardware is full of issues (on our emacs we had a to send back 70% of them for capacitor issues, macbook white the cases kept breaking, iMac 24" we had burn in from the log-in window.) Each time was a HUGE fight with apple, which are a pain to deal with. From the server side, they have even stopped making raid arrays, because they realised just how out-of-date their overpriced arrays were. Their server technology is equally as appaling, with AFP (the apple file transfer protocol used to mount home diretories) leaking memory all over the place (I have an email from apple somewhee saying that their recomendation is to set the servers to reboot once every 24-hours to fix this...)

Now, before you say I don't understand Macs, I'm ACSA (Apple Certified System Administrator) to 10.3, 10.4 and ACTC (Apple Certified Technical Co-ordinator) to 10.5 and 10.6. I have since moved away from Mac's in a corporate environment thankfully...

Mac's are great - but not in a corporate environment. They are great for that user who doesn't really know how to use a computer, who clicks yes on all popups, who needs a "playmobil, my first computer".

If you are technologically minded, you may like Apple's foundation in *nix - but after some serious digging you will get frustrated and jut install a real *nix os that hasn't been tampered with.

M. <written on a MacBook Pro running Vista/Ubuntu dual boot>
 
Mac book Pro. Some of my colleges decided to go with Airs. Its amazing how much you miss a superdrive when you don't have one.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom