OM651 Inlet manifold - replacement options - genuine/pattern/oem?

Andy!

New Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2017
Messages
13
Car
S212 E250 Sport Estate
Long time member/lurker. Had my 2011 E250 CDI parked up for about 2 years now, went into limp mode just before lock down and I've been into the office about 10 times in 2 years so just use the old land rover as I was 99% sure I knew what it was and I was no looking forward to tackling it. Sure enough i have never had to remove so much on a car to get to one part, but I am almost there and sure enough there is a nice leak down the back so either a crack or broken bolt. I also found an EGR leak due to a missing bolt resulting in a gasket being eroded away.

It is getting a complete EGR/inlet strip down clean out and replacement of every seal and gasket I can get to and a new inlet manifold and another fuel filter housing (spotted damage). I spotted what I thought was a good deal on a genuine, new inlet manifold that was listed as being "without flap actuator" and ordered it along with all genuine gaskets and o rings from Mercedes dealers. Sadly when it arrived today, despite being the same part number, it is a non-swirl flap version - I was intending to reuse my actuator and save £250.

I was quite surprised to see so many non-genuine versions on the usual European parts sites but wondered if anyone had experience with ones from brands such as Febi Bilstein (£100) or Pierburg (£216)? Anyone know who makes them for Mercedes or compared one of the non-genuine ones? I find it hard to believe that anyone would go to the expense of making injection moulding tooling for such a complex part. I normally buy genuine parts and filters unless I am sure it is the same company who makes them for Mercedes.
 

Smiley

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
2,454
No experience of these but Febi and Pierburg are well known names; I would be very surprised if the Pierburg one is not as good as the OEM one - may even be OEM.
 

Smiley

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
2,454
You may find that a third party developed the tooling and then sold the tooling to multiple different manufacturers - the world wide demand for these manifolds must mean that there is a decent market size. So it maybe that the Febi branded one came from the same tooling as an unknown brand. I've had mixed experiences with Febi parts - I would go for the Pierburg if it was my car.
 

classiccarzone

Active Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
385
Location
Ireland
Car
S203 CDI estate; S204 Cdi Estate,CL 203 X 2; Daimler V8 250 X3
I have recently completed this. There was a snapped bolt, usual one 2nd from the front at the bottom. Happened when I hit a double bump on a country road, rushing to showjumping one Sunday morning.
I used the...the.. cant remember Pierburg or Febi, but anyway not a Mercedes one. I examined it and I could not find any difference in the moulding, design or quality. I even weighed it, after cleaning the old one and allowing for the broken bolt. No perceptible difference. I even noticed a small mould number that was the same as the Original Mercedes one. You can be sure that they are all coming from the same source.

I also replaced the Diesel Filter heater/housing for the upgraded one with the three bolt holes-Mercedes Original, sourced from Germany. I even replaced the thermostat again Mercedes Original.. Renewed all the seals -Mercedes original. Cleaned everything including EGR, throttle body etc. £150.00 approx for everything.

Oil now after 500 miles is as clean as a petrol car and manifold is working perfectly,. but one day at a time

I would have been delighted to have sourced a manifold without the flaps
 
OP
OP
A

Andy!

New Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2017
Messages
13
Car
S212 E250 Sport Estate
Coming back to this, work, farming and little ones got in the way. Can get a genuine one with new motor for £360 until tomorrow night (10% off on ebay) or the Pierburg for about £200 so, given the responses above I think I will go the latter and hope the actuator is fine. Given I had a code for flaps not returning I suspect the mechanism is all gummed up and possibly worn. I had thought about fitting the flap-less one but I guess I will just get an error code? Unless I fit the actutor and just let it do it's thing? I assume the flaps must do something useful at the low rev range?

I already have a new filter housing fitted by a local specialist when I got the car but on removal I noticed that one of the hose connections has a bit of damage - looks like someone was too rough with it and by the time I buy (if they do it) a new seal I just got a new genuine one for £30 something, got a whole set of EGR gaskets (OEM) as well and a new throttle valve o-ring.

My leaking EGR made the insulation on the bulkhead very fragile and it has a hole in it, whole part is £60 metal and insulation so that will solve the common annoyance of the insulation sagging away along the top. I wonder if I have been losing boost through the leak. tbh the power for a 2.1 litre has always impressed me at how much it could shift such a big car and I would regularly get 58-60mpg on a run. Bristols impending LEZ has me wondering about replacing it with something Euro 6 but I rarely go into the city.

My tip for anyone doing this - get a very long reach 10mm spanner for the bulkhead nuts.

Thanks again for the replies
 

grober

MB Master
Joined
Jun 22, 2003
Messages
30,687
Location
Perth, Scotland
Car
W204 ESTATE
The OM651 engine is fitted to multiple vehicles- longitudinally and transversely-cars and commercial vehicles- different world markets--differing states of tune---single/twin turbo versions----its no wonder there are different variations of inlet manifold- which will fit!
chassis/engine no is your best guide to duplicate exactly.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom