MOCAŠ
MB Enthusiast
Are you sure about this? Only my understanding is that you only need to notify your insurers if you intend to rely on insurance to resolve a claim. If there's no claim theres no need to involve the insurance companies at all.
I agree you should provide your insurance details *if asked* but choosing to involve insurers or not is none of the police's business nor is it criminal if both parties agree.
I would actually say that if the damage is less than about £3000 then it is cheaper in the long term to sort things out in cash - even in a non fault accident with the other party to blame.
It comes down to what the terms of your insurance policy (a legally binding contract) demand. If they state that you have to inform the company of any accident, and you choose not to do so, then you risk having your policy cancelled if they subsequently find out about it.
There are two separate elements at play here: choosing whether to claim (whch may affect your no claims discount if it's not protected); and declaring the accident itself, which will probably result in a higher premium regardless of whether you claim, as it makes you a higher risk (statistically). Withholding this information at the time of the event is basically fraud, and the error would be compunded at each renewal for next five years if you continued not declare it.