• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

Rear tyre odd brands - Slidey

Seanalf

Active Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Messages
319
Location
Llanhilleth
Car
E220d Saloon AMG Line
When I bought my car, the previous MoT had said that a couple of tyres needed changing, I raised this with the garage (not a dealer) and they told me they had changed 3 tyres. On collection, the one they hadn't changed was also ruined, so I got them to do that as well.

Obviously they put a cheaper brand on, Accelera on the front, but they put odd brands on the rear, Kustone on one side, Catchfors on the other, not the brands I would normally have, but new tyres are new tyres right? Especially at £200 a corner. I figured I'd live with it for now, but here's te problem...

Fuel economy, I'm getting maybe 60mpg if I drive super careful, I figure cheap tyres, rubbish economy

I was coming back on the M4 Friday, honking with rain, got to the roundabout at Port Abraham, off the roundabout onto the carriegeway and the bum twitching began with a big lump of a back end slide out towards the barrier! managed to catch and return, but also a big twitch with some standing water further down. I'm thinking cheap tyres and a miss-match is more dangerous that I than I realised!

Funds are tight (rugby season has finished for me, so limited income), in the dry these are passable (I wouldn't chuck this around here anyway), but should I treat the rears as a priority to change? Given the fronts are a matching pair, I feel they can wait potentially, will putting a better set on the rears create more problems than answers? I'm not going in the whole "this brand over this brand" debate, I know what I like normally :)
 
When I bought my car, the previous MoT had said that a couple of tyres needed changing, I raised this with the garage (not a dealer) and they told me they had changed 3 tyres. On collection, the one they hadn't changed was also ruined, so I got them to do that as well.

Obviously they put a cheaper brand on, Accelera on the front, but they put odd brands on the rear, Kustone on one side, Catchfors on the other, not the brands I would normally have, but new tyres are new tyres right? Especially at £200 a corner. I figured I'd live with it for now, but here's te problem...

Fuel economy, I'm getting maybe 60mpg if I drive super careful, I figure cheap tyres, rubbish economy

I was coming back on the M4 Friday, honking with rain, got to the roundabout at Port Abraham, off the roundabout onto the carriegeway and the bum twitching began with a big lump of a back end slide out towards the barrier! managed to catch and return, but also a big twitch with some standing water further down. I'm thinking cheap tyres and a miss-match is more dangerous that I than I realised!

Funds are tight (rugby season has finished for me, so limited income), in the dry these are passable (I wouldn't chuck this around here anyway), but should I treat the rears as a priority to change? Given the fronts are a matching pair, I feel they can wait potentially, will putting a better set on the rears create more problems than answers? I'm not going in the whole "this brand over this brand" debate, I know what I like normally :)
You could price up on sites like Camskill , Asda tyres for something better like Uniroyal, Nexen or similar and then look at selling your current tyres on eBay or Facebook?
You really do have some Chinese ditchfinders on at the moment .
 
You could price up on sites like Camskill , Asda tyres for something better like Uniroyal, Nexen or similar and then look at selling your current tyres on eBay or Facebook?
You really do have some Chinese ditchfinders on at the moment .
Yeah, ASDA tyres so far coming out best with either Dunlops or Kuhmo, my pref is for Dunlops given I live in Wales and it rains here lol
 
At the very least you should be looking at a matching pair on the back. What tyre size do you need? £200 a corner for ditchfinders seems pretty steep.
£200 for good replacements :) - 275/35/19

I think these were about £100 each lol. I looked at them, the Kustone is the "better" tyre, but still a B for wet, not sure if I'd be happy with that
 
Last edited:
Yeah, ASDA tyres so far coming out best with either Dunlops or Kuhmo, my pref is for Dunlops given I live in Wales and it rains here lol
Dunlops are good.....but certainly not budget. I've had great results with Nexen in the past.....especially their NFera SU1 version. Perhaps more midpriced these days than budget.....but still far less dosh than Michelin or Pirelli etc.

My car (staggered wheels) has Bridgestone on the front.....but the PO fitted these little gems;) on the rear to get it through the MOT before he sold it. Replacing them was going to be my first job.....but as they were brand new I though Id give them a chance....so far so good. I've pushed then hard enough in the dry to howl without them letting go and used them for a wet drive to Cornwall with no drama....so unless that changes....or they have the usual cheap tyre issue of poor or uneven wear they will stay there!!
1000016761.jpg
 
I just got a very good deal at Costco for 4 tyres.

However, (a) you need to be a member - or know a member, and (b) they generally have only Michelin, Bridgestone, and Goodyear.
 
Dunlops are good.....but certainly not budget. I've had great results with Nexen in the past.....especially their NFera SU1 version. Perhaps more midpriced these days than budget.....but still far less dosh than Michelin or Pirelli etc.

My car (staggered wheels) has Bridgestone on the front.....but the PO fitted these little gems;) on the rear to get it through the MOT before he sold it. Replacing them was going to be my first job.....but as they were brand new I though Id give them a chance....so far so good. I've pushed then hard enough in the dry to howl without them letting go and used them for a wet drive to Cornwall with no drama....so unless that changes....or they have the usual cheap tyre issue of poor or uneven wear they will stay there!!
View attachment 170651
Yeah, I've tried Pirelli and Bridgestone's on my C200, Bridgestone were way better, the Dunlops are a good balance I think. I looked at Kumho as well, but the Dunlops have the edge for not a huge price difference.

If the reviews were better, I'd stick with the Kunstones, but they pretty much all say they are shite in the wet (yes, they are). Never heard of those. I had Nexens on my old Rover 75 in 225/18's and they weren't too bad, not sure if I'd trust them on the E class with the extra weight
 
I just got a very good deal at Costco for 4 tyres.

However, (a) you need to be a member - or know a member, and (b) they generally have only Michelin, Bridgestone, and Goodyear.
How much of a deal bud? Worth the membership? I'm looking at £365 for the Dunlops Sport Maxxxs'
 
How much of a deal bud? Worth the membership? I'm looking at £365 for the Dunlops Sport Maxxxs'

In my case, their price was £138 pet corner, while all the usual online retailers had it for £155-165. Then, they had a deal of additional £80 off if buying 4 Michelin tyres (which I did). So overall a saving of around £148. Obviously, different tyres have different prices, but this gives you an idea of the scale of saving (in my particular case anyway).
 
Yeah, I've tried Pirelli and Bridgestone's on my C200, Bridgestone were way better, the Dunlops are a good balance I think. I looked at Kumho as well, but the Dunlops have the edge for not a huge price difference.

If the reviews were better, I'd stick with the Kunstones, but they pretty much all say they are shite in the wet (yes, they are). Never heard of those. I had Nexens on my old Rover 75 in 225/18's and they weren't too bad, not sure if I'd trust them on the E class with the extra weight
The extra mass is taken care of by the wider tyres and sidewall construction.
 
How much of a deal bud? Worth the membership? I'm looking at £365 for the Dunlops Sport Maxxxs'
I have used Hancook tyres on Saab 9-5 which was a large and heavy car. They worked very well 👍
 
And certain caravans.....or at least they were.....now we get Leufenn....... which are actually Hancook tyres, sold under a different brand name........
 
A little tyre factoid: Nexen are OE factory fitted for BMW and VW
They worked well on my 75, felt good going through the hills to north Wales. Difference of £30 per corner

Worth a punt?

EDIT - Loads of reviews online saying they suffer badly with sidewall cracking, maybe not worth the saving
 
Last edited:
They worked well on my 75, felt good going through the hills to north Wales. Difference of £30 per corner

Worth a punt?

EDIT - Loads of reviews online saying they suffer badly with sidewall cracking, maybe not worth the saving
I dumped a set of Hankooks ( also now OE for BMW, Audi etc, because of sidewall cracks. And when I sold my S204, Motorway picked up that there was minor cracking in the tread grooves on the Goodyear Eagle F1s on it.
So it appears that you pays your money and you takes your chance...
 
I went budget ..no more expansive tyres for me ..just a good as Avon i can have 2 sets for the price of Avons ..they fiit these to planes so good enough for my car. DSC06517.JPGcar
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom