• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

W212 Vs W221

350cls

MB Enthusiast
SUPPORTER
Joined
Dec 18, 2015
Messages
2,916
Car
E55k AMG Sold / S211 E320 CDI I6 sold W212 E63 6.2 N/A saloon. S212 e250 cdi .
Just of late I have been looking at the S class W221. Being such a big car and really liking what they offer regarding speciation and options, ride quality and the extra interior room they offer, my head has been turned quite a bit.

Having owned now two AMG vehicles in the E class chassis. I have definitely scratched that itch of owning/running both amazing engine AMG cars m113k first off now currently the m156. Both have been a pleasure to own and drive on a daily basis. The ride quality of the w211 is quite something and the power a stock engine can produce and throw you back into your seat is something I was so happy and privileged to have experienced. Never thought of having the m133k tuned, was plenty fast enough for me as a stock package.

Now currently the W212 6.2 E63. When I originally changed over to this car from the w211 55. I was to read I would be making a backwards step. This has never and was the case for me. The sound of the M156 is to be experienced let alone drive a car with the brute power it offers right up to the redline if you want it too. Hand on heart i have on the odd occasion, when entering a Mway slip rd, put the hammer down and the feeling you get and the noise transmitting through the car and steering is something to make one laugh inside with the biggest grin on your face dong so. It's so addictive, but on the other hand the m156 can do all day to day drives as good as any without even getting above 2k rpm. It's worse attribute with being mpg, but the smiles it gives per miles, you forget about, and put that to the side. The ride comfort the w212 amg offers isn't as forgiving as the w211 AMG. But everything else the w212 does is better. Handling is on a different level. MCT box Vs 5 speed torque converter box. MCT really suits the car and engine, it's a really good combination. Having my w212 car to a decent condition and always maintaining it to whenever it has needed a repair or a wear and tear items to be replaced i have done so, and aways put decent brand tyres on the car. Car is driving/performing amazing for my liking.

If I were to change the car for the w221. It would be a total new area of car I would ever dive into. I have read good and bad points on the 221. Electrical issues and gear box issues, air suspension being troublesome along the way. Reading on what the 221 can offer I really feel it would appeal to me and more. But knowing my current car needs for nothing, drives amazingly well and sounds fantastic. And with it being an AMG which didn't run that long in years with the 6.2 in the w212 chassis. Would I regret doing the change to the w221. Entering the unknown is the worry I suppose and would I regret, moving on from my personal favourite engine/car I have ever owned.
 
Try an S-Class and then decide. If you later decide that you’ve made a mistake you can always get back into an E 63 or move on.
 
I think you mentioned before that you thought the M113k couldn’t be bettered and was worried that moving to the M156 might be a backward step. Once you tried the M156 you knew it was right for you. So try an S-Class and you’ll know.
 
Good write up buddy .
Would you go petrol or diesel on the W221 ?


I would much prefer a petrol W1ghty, to be honest. The 500 offers mighty performance but then again the v12 5.5 biturbo 600 offers even more. I'm a little on the fence with Diesel's especially with the ulez extension on the horizon. I wouldn't go for the 6.2 as I have that engine currently and would prefer to experience a different engine variant. The Diesels offer fantastic performance also. I would also rule out the 350 petrol as I have run that engine in the 350cls, which was a engine before they uprated the engine internals. Again lovely engine the m272.
 
Try an S-Class and then decide. If you later decide that you’ve made a mistake you can always get back into an E 63 or move on.

I see your points, but I'm not sure I would want to stay on the merry go round that long. It's rather tiresome stuff changing cars never mind going from one another so quickly. That's without the financial loss involved. Especially as I know my current w212 needs for nothing right now.if I did let it go, I might never find another to my liking. Plus the personal mods I have done to the car. Externally and internally. But as you say I need to drive the w221 myself to see where my heart is at and my head lol.
 
I'm a little on the fence with Diesel's especially with the ulez extension on the horizon...
Just an FYI: W221 S350 diesel facelift (from 2010 I think) are ULEZ exempt. I have one and absolutely love it.
Quite happy for you to have a drive in it if you're anywhere nearby (Sittingbourne)
 
Hey buddy, you should definitely try and see how you feel. I think the S class will have a smoother ride quality, will feel a lot more luxury and should have a lot more toys on board.

Which engine size would you go for? No doubt a V8 hopefully?
 
I had a 221 S320CDI with every option available, and it was the best car I've ever driven, yet I somehow didn't bond with it and sold it after a few months.
 
I love my 221, it is totally different from my prior W204. I think its just personal choice and preference.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom