What do the F1 panel make of this?

Cabe

Active Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2010
Messages
478
Location
Portsmouth
Car
W202 C220 CDI
And cup holders, and GPS, and AMG Alloys....
 
OP
OP
blondebier

blondebier

Active Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2008
Messages
605
Indeed - I think it's quite a good idea and I think they could make it work.

Anything that makes F1 safer is a good thing in my book.
 

Mr E

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
1,591
Location
Sussex
Car
57 W211 E280 AG
They'd end up looking like the LMP1 class cars.

Exactly.

F1 is an incredibly safe form of motorsport today - does it need turning into sport cars? Why not just ban it instead?
 

lancebond

Active Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2010
Messages
431
Location
Newcastle
Car
S203 C220 CDI
all comments coming from people never been anywhere near driving an F1 car professionally


i think we should ask Massa, or his family... see how they feel, that canopy would have prevented the injury altogether.

i have no problem with a canopy, it's not going to affect the sport at all as a competitive event.
 

Howard

MB Club Veteran
Joined
Apr 23, 2004
Messages
18,624
Location
Toad Hall
Car
CLS 500 / A 150
They've been using these in Class 1 Offshore Powerboating for years.

It all started after a series of rollover accidents at 140mph+ which decapitated the crews.

Princess Caroline of Monacos ex hubby , Stefano Casiraghi bought the farm this way.
 

BlackC55

Authorised Forum Sponsor
SUPPORTER
Joined
Feb 8, 2007
Messages
19,796
Location
Portsmouth, Hampshire.
Car
E55K SL500 E250X2 Smart44 Brabus Track car E450Cabriolet X350 Pick up
It just does not look right. They are supposed to be open top race cars. F1 is not safe. That is one of the reasons why people watch it and why the drivers do it.
 

LTD

MB Enthusiast
SUPPORTER
Joined
May 21, 2009
Messages
5,882
Location
Planet Earth
Car
Yep, one of THOSE !!!
If they fit them with the canopies can we stop all the restriction nonsense and get back to slicks, turbos, a gazillion horsepower and as many fuel stops as they want.

It's meant to be the pinnacle of motor racing after all ...
 

Mr E

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
1,591
Location
Sussex
Car
57 W211 E280 AG
all comments coming from people never been anywhere near driving an F1 car professionally


i think we should ask Massa, or his family... see how they feel, that canopy would have prevented the injury altogether.

i have no problem with a canopy, it's not going to affect the sport at all as a competitive event.

Or better still, ask Massa and his family why he is still racing today after the accident. Ask Schumacher why he came back after the Massa and Surtees accidents.

Even better still, put huge soft bumpers on the cars, restrict them to 30 mph and remove any whiff of danger at all...
 
D

Deleted member 37751

Guest
Will it have rain sensing-wipers?

On a serious note, won't it make the cars more aerodynamic?
 

wemorgan

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 5, 2008
Messages
8,106
Car
A205 C220d
On a serious note, won't it make the cars more aerodynamic?

Yes, but the 4 exposed wheels would remain which I imagine account for more drag than the driver's open cockpit.
 

rascalmaster

MB Enthusiast
Joined
May 5, 2010
Messages
1,411
Location
harwich, essex. UK
Car
Brabus D5 (E280 CDI) Avantgarde, E280 CDI Sport Estate, E320 Avantgarde now sold
In this age of drones and uav's surely we could leave the drivers in the Pit driving by remote :D
 

lancebond

Active Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2010
Messages
431
Location
Newcastle
Car
S203 C220 CDI
So what people are saying is we all watch F1 because it's dangerous?

Utter ********, if I wanted to watch something dangerous it certainly wouldn't be F1... a canopy makes no difference to how good a race is, but if it stops people dying (and let's face it webber is down to 1 of his 9 lives now) then why not?

Sport evolves, If this is the next step in the evolution of the sport then so be it.

MMA Used to be human cockfighting, no rules... then for safety reasons they introduced them, there has NEVER been a serious injury in the UFC because of such safeguards, does it make it less dangerous... No.

The NHL introduced new guidelines to stop the spate of concussions and neck injuries, it actually made the game faster as the more skilful players had the chance to actually play, the result a better game

At the end of the day it doesn't matter what any of us think, if the troll and the FIA decide on it, then you'll have to like it or lump it.
 

verytalldave

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 26, 2007
Messages
3,590
Location
Bromley, Kent
Car
W203 C200K Cubanite
It would be like boxing with pillows attached to your fists or horse racing wearing a pressured suit.

Some sports have - and should have - an inherent danger present to give the sport to added fillip of potential injury to the participant - if they overstep the line.
Of course many F1 dangers have been reduced by the incorporation of many design improvements over the years - and quite rightly so. But to fully encapsulate the driver in a closed car would detract too much from the visual appeal. Why not go one step further and place a giant hoop round the entire car like on public access go-karts?
You have to draw a sensible line somewhere.
This smacks of H&S going too far.
A degree of danger is an important element of F1 and must remain so. Its one of the reasons its so popular.
Its why the pay is so damn good and after all, nobody is forced to take part.
 
Last edited:

dulayj

Active Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2011
Messages
539
Location
Near Winchester
Car
A 210/Volvo XC90
Always interesting to read so many varied views-my 2pence worth-technology advances generally have not detracted from viewing pleasure if you like the sport in the first place. e.g Cricket and helmets etc
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom