SpikyMikey
Hardcore MB Enthusiast
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2020
- Messages
- 14,067
- Location
- The Sunny South Coast
- Car
- BMW F31 330i LCI M Sport Shadow Edition AMG Black Series Touring
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
On the contrary , those who drive robotically on auto pilot aren't necessarily aware of anything at all , because they aren't looking or considering anything .Can't agree.
For drivers to indicate at all shows some consideration to others, and thought about the driving process.
Yes many get it wrong and might even introduce some confusion.
Here we should try to anticipate the less skilful, and remember that as well as indictors not giving a right to their intent, that they also shouldn't be relied on for accuracy of intent.
But I view that those that don't use indicators are 2D drivers with little appreciation of the wider road activities around them.
Correct use of indictors can need a skill.
To not use them is selfish and likely lazy.
Maybe not the best example.
I'm on the motorway inside lane and and leaving at the next junction.
I invariably start to signal my intent at the 300m mark.
That allows those behind to plan their lane, if to overtake or also leave behind me.
Many don't bother or signal as they cross the white painty bits, cos they're in the inside lane (more often but not always) so why bother, I assume.
A following driver can rarely interpret whether another driver has determined a signal is necessary or not ; direction signals are not always required , and if not required , should not be used .Original:
Ironically you could substitute each instance of of “unnecessary signalling” with “lack of signalling”.
On the contrary , those who drive robotically on auto pilot aren't necessarily aware of anything at all , because they aren't looking or considering anything .
Advanced drivers , who have been trained to observe , plan and act according to the circumstances will do whatever is appropriate at any given time , and not do what is not appropriate .
Getting a snapshot of another driver doing or not doing something on a single occasion gives you no clue as to their competence .
Your example of leaving a motorway or dual carriageway - you may need to start your system a lot more than 300m from the exit - depends entirely on the circumstances - I usually start planning an exit AT LEAST a mile before the exit , sometimes even further than that ; I may not need to take the left lane that early , or even at all if multiple lanes exit , other times I will start to get in the appropriate lane one or more miles before the exit - it all depends on circumstances , and if I am subsequently turning right the appropriate lane might be the rightmost exiting lane of which there may be two , three or more , because I want the right hand lane after the exit , which is common if a motorway exit leads down to a roundabout , which many do - every case is different .
People always seem to focus on direction signals for some reason ( there are many different kinds of visible and audible signals too ) - signals should only be given if they will be of benefit to another road user ; in the hypothetical exit scenario you raised , they rarely will benefit anyone : if you are already in the leftmost lane , a signal to exit will benefit no one - you are already on course and following traffic can either exit after you or continue ahead ; you should be maintaining your speed until you have left the main carriageway so should not affect following traffic ; if you have to slow because of traffic ahead of you that is a separate issue - I might be passing an exit and forced to slow because of traffic ahead , yet not be exiting , so I give no signal ; traffic behind can change lane or not as they wish ; that I happen to be exiting is no concern of theirs , they can do whatever they wish regardless . Similarly , I approach a T junction where I could turn left or right ; there is only room for one vehicle to exit at a time - what possible benefit is a direction signal to a car behind ? They cannot go until I have gone and then they can turn left or right as they please - a direction signal does not help them at all . If the mouth of the junction has space for vehicles to position left or right , I will position as appropriate , in some cases I might feel it would help a following vehicle and I will signal ; other times it is of no benefit and my position on the road will clearly indicate where I am going , they can follow behind , or they can come alongside if going the other way .
Yes , it often does happen that signals will help others and then they should be given , but not always - far too many people do it without any thought because it is taught to novices who don't have the skill or experience to decide . There has been a long established adage that a well driven car rarely needs to signal because the driver's intentions are clear .
So much of driving depends entirely on prevalent circumstances , which can differ according to so many factors - yet so many drivers never vary their behaviour at any point , because they are acting robotically and not considering anything that is going on around them - these are the drivers we all need to watch out for .
A bit shy!BIGDOG,
how many words was that?
Can’t say I noticed mate. I was on my phone.Key question Anton.
Was he indicating?
Well that dog could just as easily have been a child chasing a ball into the road , or a pedestrian stepping out ( not even necessarily at a junction ) and the Rover driver cannot be faulted for stopping to avoid a collision - in that instance the fault was entirely on Mr BMW for driving too close or not paying enough attention , as you rightly said , and his insurers would have been picking up the tab .I'll answer this with my own similar account. When driving around the Guilford bypass at 3:20pm on a sunny August afternoon ..... sorry, I'll keep it shorter. The Rover in front of me braked sharply to a stop, as did I and then the mini behind me. Then just as the car in front of me pulled away I heard a loud crunch followed by my car being shunted forward a little. Just as I got out of my car an irate guy came up to me shouting the odds and wanting to know why I'd stopped when nothing was there. Looking back I could see then the mini was now about half its original length, with a BMW implanted in its boot. The mini driver looked OK. The BMW driver eventually stopped ranting long enough for me to explain about the now invisible Rover, but he didn't believe me.
Then a stranger walked up to us and said he was the Rover driver and that he had braked heavily because a dog ran out in front of him. The BMW driver then changed his attitude and said "Well you know how it is when you're at the back of a line of cars - you have less time to stop." To which I replied, "Yes, I know that. Which is why I leave an even greater gap in those circumstances - you should try it."
And that is often what causes shunts. That and not paying attention. NOT pedestrians crossing the road where they may be expected to do so.
The Highway Code doesn't encourage pedestrians to just walk out into traffic and expect everyone to stop for them. That's just the interpretation by click bait attracting media nonsense and ill-informed people. The HC commences with Rules 1 to 35 that are for pedestrians and includes general guidance on safely crossing the road, and situations needing extra care. Rule 7 includes " If traffic is coming, let it pass. Look all around again and listen. Do not cross until there is a safe gap in the traffic and you are certain that there is plenty of time."
The HC is a collection of rules; guidance that only works when considered in total, not piecemeal. All road users, no matter whether on foot, horse or wheels, need to be fully educated to make the roads safe for everyone.
It is actively taught not to do it at police college , and will be noted as an unnecessary signal on an advanced test . Like so many other bad habits , it is robotic rather than considered , and especially poor on single carriageway , two way roads , as opposed to multi lane roads where people are more likely to continue in the overtaking lane . One particularly bad practice , where it often happens is when approaching the exit of a motorway or DC , some drivers fail to get into the left lane in good time , or even embark on a pointless overtake just before the exit , then cut across the bows of vehicles correctly using the left lane , and who may be continuing straight ahead anyway - it does not gain them any time and risks a collision , yet so many feel it is imperative to overtake one last vehicle before exiting . I remember one idiot in a JAAAG who came flying down lane two of the M74 as I was passing an exit , and just started pushing over towards me , expecting me to be exiting , even though I wasn't ; I blasted my horn before he hit me , and he ended up stopping in lane two , with other traffic behind me also continuing straight ahead !
HC is a book of not always good advice , and these days seems to be written by people who are not particularly qualified to do so ; I'm sure much of its content is politically motivated by minority and anti-motoring groups in its current incarnation .
Unnecessary signalling is just one of many indicators of robotic driving where people proceed blindly down the road without putting any active thought into their driving and usually have very poor observation .
The signal is not in of itself harmful , but it is an indication of a robotic driver who is blind to everything going on around them - and these people ARE extremely dangerous . There is also the point that by eliminating unnecessary actions , such as needless signals , gearchanges and other 'habits' that some pick up , the driving becomes more efficient , smoother and easier , as well as safer .
One of the main points of teaching advanced driving , is to raise driving to a more conscious level so that drivers are putting full attention into their driving , and not treating as some sort of subconscious subroutine - which far too many people on the roads do .
On the contrary , those who drive robotically on auto pilot aren't necessarily aware of anything at all , because they aren't looking or considering anything .
Advanced drivers , who have been trained to observe , plan and act according to the circumstances will do whatever is appropriate at any given time , and not do what is not appropriate .
Getting a snapshot of another driver doing or not doing something on a single occasion gives you no clue as to their competence .
Your example of leaving a motorway or dual carriageway - you may need to start your system a lot more than 300m from the exit - depends entirely on the circumstances - I usually start planning an exit AT LEAST a mile before the exit , sometimes even further than that ; I may not need to take the left lane that early , or even at all if multiple lanes exit , other times I will start to get in the appropriate lane one or more miles before the exit - it all depends on circumstances , and if I am subsequently turning right the appropriate lane might be the rightmost exiting lane of which there may be two , three or more , because I want the right hand lane after the exit , which is common if a motorway exit leads down to a roundabout , which many do - every case is different .
People always seem to focus on direction signals for some reason ( there are many different kinds of visible and audible signals too ) - signals should only be given if they will be of benefit to another road user ; in the hypothetical exit scenario you raised , they rarely will benefit anyone : if you are already in the leftmost lane , a signal to exit will benefit no one - you are already on course and following traffic can either exit after you or continue ahead ; you should be maintaining your speed until you have left the main carriageway so should not affect following traffic ; if you have to slow because of traffic ahead of you that is a separate issue - I might be passing an exit and forced to slow because of traffic ahead , yet not be exiting , so I give no signal ; traffic behind can change lane or not as they wish ; that I happen to be exiting is no concern of theirs , they can do whatever they wish regardless . Similarly , I approach a T junction where I could turn left or right ; there is only room for one vehicle to exit at a time - what possible benefit is a direction signal to a car behind ? They cannot go until I have gone and then they can turn left or right as they please - a direction signal does not help them at all . If the mouth of the junction has space for vehicles to position left or right , I will position as appropriate , in some cases I might feel it would help a following vehicle and I will signal ; other times it is of no benefit and my position on the road will clearly indicate where I am going , they can follow behind , or they can come alongside if going the other way .
Yes , it often does happen that signals will help others and then they should be given , but not always - far too many people do it without any thought because it is taught to novices who don't have the skill or experience to decide . There has been a long established adage that a well driven car rarely needs to signal because the driver's intentions are clear .
So much of driving depends entirely on prevalent circumstances , which can differ according to so many factors - yet so many drivers never vary their behaviour at any point , because they are acting robotically and not considering anything that is going on around them - these are the drivers we all need to watch out for .
Methinks that using up the threads daily word allowance to stop other people answering is cheating.Well that dog could just as easily have been a child chasing a ball into the road , or a pedestrian stepping out ( not even necessarily at a junction ) and the Rover driver cannot be faulted for stopping to avoid a collision - in that instance the fault was entirely on Mr BMW for driving too close or not paying enough attention , as you rightly said , and his insurers would have been picking up the tab .
As for rule 7 , which I am well aware of , it is immediately followed by , and contradicted by , rule 8 , which says
"At a junction. When you are crossing or waiting to cross the road, other traffic should give way. Look out for traffic turning into the road, especially from behind you, and cross at a place where drivers can see you. If you have started crossing and traffic wants to turn into the road, you have priority and they should give way (see Rules H2 and 170)."
This is why HC is so poor , it is so inconsistent that one rule is contradicted by the very next one , and so much of it is just so badly written it needs to be torn up and started again by people with actual qualifications suitable for authoring it , which the current lot clearly are not , and who deserve a huge F for fail .
I could do better myself
Whilst I totally agree with this, I have no issue with anyone I see giving an unnecessary but still correct signal. To me it's additional information that MAY prove to be useNor have
no issue with anyone I see giving an unnecessary bu
Whilst I totally agree with this, I have no issue with anyone I see giving an unnecessary but still correct signal. To me it's additional infor
Now that is one rule I've never heard ofMethinks that using up the threads daily word allowance to stop other people answering is cheating.
Nor have I , but sometimes if you follow another driver far enough , you can formulate an impression of their driving , which might be either good or bad .Whilst I totally agree with this, I have no issue with anyone I see giving an unnecessary but still correct signal. To me it's additional information that MAY prove to be useful.
It's in the Internet Forum Code.Now that is one rule I've never heard of![]()
Could have been a newly qualified driver , first time ever on a motorway , and very nervous , or someone's grandmother - same .I followed a car down a slip road today (junction 44 M74 Carlisle) at 35mph. What a palaver it was joining the motorway.![]()
I'm sorry and not sure where you get your allegedly qualified info....but that's wrong....and potentially illegal. A two second Google backed what I already knew but..if you are already in the leftmost lane , a signal to exit will benefit no one - you are already on course and following traffic can either exit after you or continue ahead ; you should be maintaining your speed until you have left the main carriageway so should not affect following traffic ; if you have to slow because of traffic ahead of you that is a separate issue - I might be passing an exit and forced to slow because of traffic ahead , yet not be exiting , so I give no signal
Former advanced instructor at Scottish Police College , Tulliallan , as was another member of this forum , and that is what we taught students . Also still current as an emergency responder with the fire service . Have also been a member of all the civilian advanced driving organisations , as well as an instructor for them .I'm sorry and not sure where you get your allegedly qualified info....but that's wrong....and potentially illegal. A two second Google backed what I already knew but..
In the UK, while the Highway Code states you should signal when exiting a dual carriageway or motorway if you will need to cross a broken white line to do so, which although is advisory, failing to do so can lead to a charge of driving without due care and attention, which is a legal offence. Sounds like you are most likely one of those my wife likes to shout at on the road .. " you might be psychic mate but I'm not.....INDICATE!". Also it's annoying for following cars as they don't know if you are leaving....and assume you are staying on the road....leading them to make an unnecessary overtake which they would not have if they had known you were leaving. Just manners really.
I'd far rather do something extra and possibly not legally required, than risk getting done for not doing it. Especially when there are no obvious downsides to doing it. Would most on here be happy to leave a motorway, with a cop car right behind them, without indicating, legal or not? I certainly wouldn't!
I'll leave this one to you obvious "experts".
Don’t believe ya!…….I really am out now!
The A55 has some very short exit slip roads. To exit onto those at even 50 would be hazardous.If there is no traffic ahead of you , then you should not be slowing down until you have actually left the carriageway
Remind me - who was it that started all this recording of Non Crime Hate Incidents? Oh yes, it was the College of Policing; clearly we should always follow their instructions.Former advanced instructor at Scottish Police College , Tulliallan , opportunity .
When I encounter those situations, I hold well back then as soon as the snail has left the slip road I accelerate hard up to the requisite speed for safer entry.I followed a car down a slip road today (junction 44 M74 Carlisle) at 35mph. What a palaver it was joining the motorway.![]()
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.