Diamond cut, or polished finish looks great though. Sure it's relatively weak from a durability perspective, but if you're lucky and treat the wheels well then you should get 3+ years before the white worm begins to show, quite easily longer.
It wasn't that long ago that only specialised wheel refurbers could repair diamond cut, now pretty much everyone can do it, so costs have come down to, or at least very close, to a regular wheel refurb.
For this reason I'd get them diamond cut again. When the sun shines on a polished alloy wheel face with no paint (only lacquer) on it, you can't beat the shine.
I had the dealer refurb all four alloys on my W212 before I agreed to buy it (approved used), diamond cut as it left the factory, and the quality of work (third party local refurber) is near as dammit to that of a factory finish. If they last as long as the originals I'll be happy.