W212 Subframe Corrosion MOT Failure

if y
Crikey!!! Seems like a lot of European OEMs skipped on the rust proofing in the 2010s. Glad you're ok though.

I saw your old car for sale too, I'd like to know a bit more about it actually (but I can't send DMs on here). Looks like an amazing spec!

I'm between the M156 and M157, I can't decide.
if you have insta you can msg me on good.clean.wholesome
 
Good evening all, I am a day old on this forum but can see already what a usefull place it is.
I bought my 2009 Mercedes E350 CDi W207/C207 Coupe with 82k mileage from a dealer on Jan 7th 26.
I had checked out the MOT history before I went to view the car and had noticed that there was an airbag recall on it, so after taking possession I booked the car in to MB Group1 Nottingham for the FOC recall.
During the the time (it was in the garage yesterday) they carried out a free health check which reported that the anti roll bar drag link boots were cracked, the rear propshaft rubber coupling had signs of cracks in the rubber and that there was a small hole surounded by corrosion on the subframe which could only be rectified by fitting a new subframe.
The young lady who had been dealing with me mentioned that she had put through a request (presumably to MB UK HQ) for a free goodwill replacement & was awaiting a responce but was hopefull that it would be possitive, when she returned it was obviouse from her face that it was not a possitive responce and in fact they had refused the request outright, not even offereing a contribution.
When I asked for a reason she produced the photostat copies of genuine MB service history for my car that does not go beyond 2016 so I pointed out that I had this information but that it had been regularly serviced up to and including Oct 25 but by independant certified garages and that I had the invoices/documents.
I have since sent emails to the service manager who stated:
No reason is given on the goodwill request. Ultimately all the subframe replacements are done on a case-by-case basis.
This is impacted over several factors that allow Mercedes-Benz to make the decision.
So I am now wondering where to go next!
As I see it a subframe that carries suspension & brakes is a safety critical structure and if it is known that it has been manufactured using sub standard material, it should be subject to a recall just as the airbag issue is.
Any ideas on how many out there have the same problem.
Would joint approach to MB UK be worthwhile?
Terry C.
 
Last edited:
As you only bought the car last month I suspect your best bet would be to contact the garage you bought it from, on the basis that it's potentially unsafe.


Dozens of other threads on subframe issues here (both past and current), which it might be worth skimming through.
 
Good evening all, I am a day old on this forum but can see already what a usefull place it is.
I bought my 2009 Mercedes E350 CDi W207/C207 Coupe with 82k mileage from a dealer on Jan 7th 26.
I had checked out the MOT history before I went to view the car and had noticed that there was an airbag recall on it, so after taking possession I booked the car in to MB Group1 Nottingham for the FOC recall.
During the the time (it was in the garage yesterday) they carried out a free health check which reported that the anti roll bar drag link boots were cracked, the rear propshaft rubber coupling had signs of cracks in the rubber and that there was a small hole surounded by corrosion on the subframe which could only be rectified by fitting a new subframe.
The young lady who had been dealing with me mentioned that she had put through a request (presumably to MB UK HQ) for a free goodwill replacement & was awaiting a responce but was hopefull that it would be possitive, when she returned it was obviouse from her face that it was not a possitive responce and in fact they had refused the request outright, not even offereing a contribution.
When I asked for a reason she produced the photostat copies of genuine MB service history for my car that does not go beyond 2016 so I pointed out that I had this information but that it had been regularly serviced up to and including Oct 25 but by independant certified garages and that I had the invoices/documents.
I have since sent emails to the service manager who stated:
No reason is given on the goodwill request. Ultimately all the subframe replacements are done on a case-by-case basis.
This is impacted over several factors that allow Mercedes-Benz to make the decision.
So I am now wondering where to go next!
As I see it a subframe that carries suspension & brakes is a safety critical structure and if it is known that it has been manufactured using sub standard material, it should be subject to a recall just as the airbag issue is.
Any ideas on how many out there have the same problem.
Would joint approach to MB UK be worthwhile?
Terry C.
Welcome to the forum and sorry to hear about your news.

As said, many, many threads on here about the subframe failure.

Mercedes were offering goodwill (note : this was not a warranty) replacements or contributions toward replacement costs but that has pretty much dried up. Service history doesn't seem to be a factor in the decision process either.

Mercedes are under no legal obligation to help and there has never been a recall for this issue by VOSA.

Yes it is safety critical if not dealt with but so are worn brakes, suspension, steering etc and a manufacturer cannot be held liable for ever.

Subframes are bolt on parts subject to corrosion and as such can be seen as service items. The Subframe on your vehicle has lasted 17 years so saying it is sub standard is a difficult argument to make and some people have had 10 year old cars turned down.

As said, the dealer who sold you the car is wholly liable, the fault was clearly pre existing when you brought the car and the dealer is liable to either repair it or refund you in the first 6 months with a reasonable allowance for mileage.

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
....W207/C207 Coupe with 82k mileage from a dealer on Jan 7th 26....
So I am now wondering where to go next!

Straight back to the trader who sold you the car, as BTB 500 said. It's really your only option. And make sure that the dealer provides you with a written report detailing all the faults found.
 
As you only bought the car last month I suspect your best bet would be to contact the garage you bought it from, on the basis that it's potentially unsafe.


Dozens of other threads on subframe issues here (both past and current), which it might be worth skimming through.
Thanks BTB, but it would be unreasonable to prove that the dealer knew that he had sold a car with a hole in the subframe as it was not picked up on the MOT carried out in October 25.
It is surely more reasonable to persue the issue through MB UK who know that they had built the car using a Structural part that was manufactured with flawed/ sub standard material.
Also there was a six month warranty given with the car which I have already used to cover the cost of replacing the oil cooler which had a leak and new battery .But thank you for your input.
 
Thanks BTB, but it would be unreasonable to prove that the dealer knew...

It does not come into it.

All traders are bound to provide a statutory warranty under the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

No one is suggesting thar the seller was dishonest. The statutory warranty is just the cost of doing business.
 

"If a car develops a fault within the first 30 days of purchase, it is under statutory warranty and the buyer can simply reject it and return it to the dealer for a refund.

If a fault emerges between 30 days and six months from the date of purchase, the law assumes that the fault was pre-existing and, unless the seller can prove otherwise, the vehicle is still protected by statutory warranty. Here, the seller has one chance to fix the problem. If they do not manage to do that, the buyer is entitled to a refund, which may be less than the original purchase price to account for the time during which the car has been functional.

After six months, the automatic protection of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 expires. It is up to the buyer to prove that there was a fault with the car at the time of purchase if they want to pursue a dealer for a claim to repair a fault.

Note that the statutory warranty on a used car only applies here to cars bought from a dealer. Private purchasers enjoy none of this protection and the rules for cars bought at auction will depend on the particular auction house, and whether it was online or not."

It's the law.
 
Thanks BTB, but it would be unreasonable to prove that the dealer knew that he had sold a car with a hole in the subframe as it was not picked up on the MOT carried out in October 25.
It is surely more reasonable to persue the issue through MB UK who know that they had built the car using a Structural part that was manufactured with flawed/ sub standard material.
Also there was a six month warranty given with the car which I have already used to cover the cost of replacing the oil cooler which had a leak and new battery .But thank you for your input.
No, absolutely not.

As said. MB have no responsibility here. The car is 17 years old.

In law it is entirely the selling dealers respondility regardless of if they knew or not.

The six month warranty is to protect the dealer, not you.

The subframe is a separate issue and MB are not going to pay, realistically at 17 years why should they?
 
Good evening all, I am a day old on this forum but can see already what a usefull place it is.
I bought my 2009 Mercedes E350 CDi W207/C207 Coupe with 82k mileage from a dealer on Jan 7th 26.
I had checked out the MOT history before I went to view the car and had noticed that there was an airbag recall on it, so after taking possession I booked the car in to MB Group1 Nottingham for the FOC recall.
During the the time (it was in the garage yesterday) they carried out a free health check which reported that the anti roll bar drag link boots were cracked, the rear propshaft rubber coupling had signs of cracks in the rubber and that there was a small hole surounded by corrosion on the subframe which could only be rectified by fitting a new subframe.
The young lady who had been dealing with me mentioned that she had put through a request (presumably to MB UK HQ) for a free goodwill replacement & was awaiting a responce but was hopefull that it would be possitive, when she returned it was obviouse from her face that it was not a possitive responce and in fact they had refused the request outright, not even offereing a contribution.
When I asked for a reason she produced the photostat copies of genuine MB service history for my car that does not go beyond 2016 so I pointed out that I had this information but that it had been regularly serviced up to and including Oct 25 but by independant certified garages and that I had the invoices/documents.
I have since sent emails to the service manager who stated:
No reason is given on the goodwill request. Ultimately all the subframe replacements are done on a case-by-case basis.
This is impacted over several factors that allow Mercedes-Benz to make the decision.
So I am now wondering where to go next!
As I see it a subframe that carries suspension & brakes is a safety critical structure and if it is known that it has been manufactured using sub standard material, it should be subject to a recall just as the airbag issue is.
Any ideas on how many out there have the same problem.
Would joint approach to MB UK be worthwhile?
Terry C.
My W212 failed the mot on the rear subframe. Mercedes replaced it free of charge under their 30 year anti-corrosion warrant. I had the car from new it was about 11years old at the time with full MB history. I have come across other owners with the same issue and had it replaced at there own expense. I think full service history was key.
 
My W212 failed the mot on the rear subframe. Mercedes replaced it free of charge under their 30 year anti-corrosion warrant. I had the car from new it was about 11years old at the time with full MB history. I have come across other owners with the same issue and had it replaced at there own expense. I think full service history was key.
No they did not replace it under the 30 year warranty. That only applies to body panels that cortode from the inside to out. It doesn't apply to components attached to the vehicle.
Again, service history was never the key point, many have been replaced under goodwill that didn't have full history but as has been said many times, that goodwill was limited in time and scope.
 
No they did not replace it under the 30 year warranty. That only applies to body panels that cortode from the inside to out. It doesn't apply to components attached to the vehicle.
Again, service history was never the key point, many have been replaced under goodwill that didn't have full history but as has been said many times, that goodwill was limited in time and scope.
If the poster just assumed this (the 30 year warranty thing), then fair enough. But if that's what the dealer told them, were they just making it up? If so, why not just tell the truth and say it was goodwill? Seems strange to me and only serves to muddy the waters.
 
If the poster just assumed this (the 30 year warranty thing), then fair enough. But if that's what the dealer told them, were they just making it up? If so, why not just tell the truth and say it was goodwill? Seems strange to me and only serves to muddy the waters.
Who knows?

Many people misinterpret the terms and conditions of the anti perforation warranty and also seem unable to differentiate between what goodwill and warranty means.
 
100% on the dealer. whether they knew about it or didnt doesn't matter at all. your only hope is to use the consumer rights act and immediately return the car.

it is 0% the responsibility of mercedes benz unless the car is within a warranty window relating to the issue.

IMG-20251114-WA0001.jpg
IMG-20251104-WA0006.jpg
this happened to my m3 and cost me 4k to replace the subframe because just the subframe and control arm that bent cost 2.5k...
 

"If a car develops a fault within the first 30 days of purchase, it is under statutory warranty and the buyer can simply reject it and return it to the dealer for a refund.

If a fault emerges between 30 days and six months from the date of purchase, the law assumes that the fault was pre-existing and, unless the seller can prove otherwise, the vehicle is still protected by statutory warranty. Here, the seller has one chance to fix the problem. If they do not manage to do that, the buyer is entitled to a refund, which may be less than the original purchase price to account for the time during which the car has been functional.

After six months, the automatic protection of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 expires. It is up to the buyer to prove that there was a fault with the car at the time of purchase if they want to pursue a dealer for a claim to repair a fault.

Note that the statutory warranty on a used car only applies here to cars bought from a dealer. Private purchasers enjoy none of this protection and the rules for cars bought at auction will depend on the particular auction house, and whether it was online or not."

It's the law.
Hi Mark, thank you for your input.
I understand what your report advises but it is as always a little more convaluted.
My car came with a 6 month warranty which I have activated following on from a car no start situation that occured just short of a month after my purchase & this showed itself as a flashing glow plug dash light and a no start.
The warrant company stipulate that they must autherise any work before it commences.
I arranged to get the car delivered to a MB independant specialst who diagnosed the fault as a module but also found that the oil cooler was leaking and required replacement, + the main battery was not holding charge so this needed to be replaced too.
The estimate for all of this work was around £2500 and the warranty company autherised a contribution of £1200.
The work has been carried out, I should also note that within two weeks of my purchase I noticed water dripping from the interior mirror and because I am friendly with a independant windscreen fitter "who I have used on my classic cars" I asked his advise, It was due to de-lamination & required to be taken out cleaned and re-placed and all is now fine, I felt it wasnt worth involving the warranty for the sake of £100.
So after the Warranty company have paid me their contribution I am out of pocket already to the tune of £1300.
Now that this was all sorted I decided to arrange to take the car to Group1 MB dealership for its FOC front air bag recall and it was during this that they carried out the video health check.
The purpose of this rambling is to show how things escalate and why it does not work/add up for me to take the car back, even if the dealer were ageeable to give me my £3850 back as I have already improved the car at a cost of £1300.
I have contacted the dealer who I bought the car from to ask for his thoughts He He!!!
I have escalated further my request to Group1 MB Nottingham to ask them for a reason why my subframe goodwill request was refused outright.
Following a very helpfull reply from Mark Jay, I have priced a new aftermarket subframe and the manufacturer is close to me in Nottingham for £214 so if all else fails I will ask my local tamed classic car friendly garage to fit it for me.
Best wishes.
Terry.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom