• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

ThemeScene HD72i Projector

BenzComander

MB Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
1,044
Location
Bucks
Car
E320 Avantgarde Estate
Thinking that we might invest in a roof mounted projector for our house, as we have a large wall in the living room that could be used as the screen. Our thoughts are bigger picture for less cash than an LCD/Plasma TV, as we would only use it for watching films and major sporting events. We already have a 37" crt for the kids and general viewing.

The ThemeScene HD72i Projector seems to get a good write up, anybody got any experience of this or similar priced projectors??

Thanks.
 
That's cheap for a projector bulb.

You'll need a good screen to project onto - it comes with a free one though you can opt for a mount instead. You also need to check the throw to the wall and the angle you'll be mounting it from - the wife may not like the idea of a large mount hanging from the roof! It really depends on how big the room is - how much natural light there is and what quality you want. This is a DLP not an LCD projector - I've only worked with expensive DLP projectors so not sure what the colour saturation is like with one DLP chip vs an equivalent LCD.

You really need to see them in action as everyone has a differing perception of what image they like.
 
smartbrabus said:
£210 for a bulb? Are they 'avin a laugh?

Actually , it's a LAMP . A bulb is something you plant in your garden :D

I agree it looks reasonable for the money , this price point is really LCD territory . Optoma have been on the go for a number of years now , mainly in the conference/presentation market , and are a reasonably well respected brand .

However , I'd be keen to see (and hear) it in operation before buying . Some of these small projectors can be quite acceptable - others are dreadful .

They do claim 'low fan noise' but some DLP projectors also have what is known as a 'colour wheel' which emits a sound constantly varying in pitch and can be most distracting .

They quote contrast ratios of 3500:1 and 5000:1 (this describes the difference between brightest whites and darkest blacks the unit can produce) , again reasonable figures for a small projector but nowhere near what a CRT is capable of (my CRT projector has a contrast ratio of 18,000:1 and a direct view CRT television set will better even this figure many times over) : all I am trying to say here is - please DO try to see the unit working before you buy , depending on how critical you are you may , or may not , be happy with the picture quality it can offer . Oh - and if you go for a demo take along a DVD of a film with good , natural photography , something like "House of Flying Daggers" - DO NOT let them demo the unit with the latest Pixar-type production like "Cars" or "Ice Age" which is effectively computer graphics with bright , saturated colours which do not allow you to judge what the projector is capable of .

You certainly can get DLP projectors capable of rivalling the quality of your local cinema but these machines (some of the larger models made by Christie Digital for example) cost the price of a small house and need expert set up and maintenance to give of their best (I used to install and service these units in a couple of previous jobs) .

I must echo what has been said already about using a decent screen : a white wall just won't cut it . Screens come with all kinds of different surfaces , each with their own characteristics : a matte screen surface will look most natural , a beaded one will give a wider viewing angle for people sitting off to one side . Don't mount it too high up or it will be like sitting in the front row of the cinema , craning your neck to see .

Also look at different mounts - the industry standard is Unicol www.unicol.com not as cheap as the ones advertised but much better engineered and with proper adjustments .

Do remember that projector lamps have a finite lifespan , normally quoted in hours , anything from as little as 1000 hours to perhaps 3000 hours if you're lucky .

Since you say you plan to keep your CRT TV and just use this for watching the occasional film , this should be OK . Not sure that I'd want to use one as my main viewing screen in the house .

Hope this is of help.
 
Last edited:
Pontoneer said:
Actually , it's a LAMP . A bulb is something you plant in your garden :D

Damn! that'll be why I didn't get a crop of replacement LCD Projector bulbs this autumn!

Echoing all of the above ambient light is a real issue with projectors and you need to look the real cost of replacing 'consumables'. Cheaper replacement lamps usually mean shorter lamp life (the dreaded 'mean time before failure' statistic). For a little extra you may be able to get a demonstration in your home. Use the rules Pontoneer has already laid out, your disk your rules. Remember analogue TV looks poor when projected on a big screen as you get to see all the lines the picture is made up of.

Look at where the external light sources are in the room and how they could interfere with your view, and, as mentioned already, listen for fan noise, projectors sold as 'quiet' can often have temperature sensitive fans which will kick in just at the wrong time in your film!
 
Thanks for the advice everbody, will go and take a look as suggested! Will report back with findings!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom