W202 Replacement Dilemma

[niva441]

As you can see from the classified section, I think the time has come to replace my wonderful W202 C250TD. There's nothing actually wrong with it and, unusually for me, I haven't grown bored with it. However at the
moment I'm racking up 2000 miles a month (even though I only drive the car twice a week) and she isn't getting any younger.

The biggest problem I'm having with this car is what to replace it with. As I've just sold my house, cash isn't an immediate problem. Well not until I realise I need a roof over my head. After having a Mercedes I can't have a normal car, only a Mercedes will do.

As I will need another house at some stage and have a natural reluctance to spend money (less so for cars), my final choices aren't too exotic. I've narrowed it down to either a couple of years old C270 or, in exchange for a smaller house, a new C220 Sport Coupe.

I've tried going through the pros and cons, but not actually managed to achieve an answer, any ideas?

 

[fuzzer]

go drive both , 220 sports coupe will be very close to your 250td if not faster and more economical.

drive the 270 and you will want it .

 

[niva441]

I tried a 220 and 270 saloon a couple of years ago. Although the 220 is now quick enough as it's as powerful as my 250, it's not as smooth and instantly responsive as the 5 cylinder.

Plus as I understand from forums the lastest EU4 spec 4 cylinder engines are no more economical than the 5 cylinder.

Now if I could get a 5 cylinder Sport Coupe...

 

[niva441]

Went to the Merc dealer and tested the Sport Coupe. Overall I was happy with it, much improved over the earlier models, although the engine was a bit rough.

Started talking numbers with the dealer, it seems they weren't interested in doing much of a deal, particularly with regard to my current car. Evidently marque loyalty isn't rated too highly.

So I started looking for alternatives. Checked out the spec of the BMW 1 series. In simple terms it's cheaper, faster and more economical, plus with the fixed servicing deal I won't be fleeced by the dealer.

So, much as I've never been a BMW fan (particularly after working for Rover/Land Rover), I've order a 120d.

The major problem with it will be spending the next couple of years apologising for the badge.

Thank you for all your help, I'll be back.