• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

What a nightmare... Thanks Merc

Iyse

Active Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
292
Location
Leamington Spa
Car
Porsche Boxster
OK, so about 4 days ago I recieved the following from Eurocarparts:

2x Front brake discs
4x Front brake pads
2x Rear brake discs
4x Rear brake pads
2x Pad wear sensor

After getting home from a 9am lecture, I bring everything I need outside, chock the backs, jack and stand the front, off with the wheels and I try to locate the first nut on my way to removing the calipers. Once the search is over, out comes the manual torque wrench and I give it a good yank... Nothing. Once again, with a bit more force. Still nothing. After 20 minutes of desperately trying to get this nut off, I decide to give up, as electronic wrenches are probably better suited for this job.

Defeated, I call Mercedes of Coventry (which I always hate doing), go through to service and ask for my car to be booked in. Now, as I live quite a while away from Coventry, I naturally ask for a courtesy car, and as a Mercedes owner, one would expect nothing less. The guy I was speaking to obviously wasn't Enlglish, and had a very slimy way of speaking, almost as if he was patronising me without putting in the effort to do so. After 5 minutes of silence from the other end as he put my details in for the job to be done, I started to get a little annoyed.

"Is there a problem?" I asked, frustrated.

"I'm just putting your details in now." Surely it doesn't take more than a minute to book a car in for a brake replacement. I could picture him deliberately slowing the process just to piss me off as he sensed the tired angst in my voice.

The quote was £330 including VAT, which is £95 an hour for 3 hours. 1.6 hours for the front and 1.4 for the back. I knew it was going to be extortionate, so I bit the bullet and agreed to book my car in. Next came the courtesy car, and it seems that if you want to inconvenience Mercedes, they will do everything in their power to return to favour.

"If you want a courtesy car, we can do the job in 2 weeks."

"TWO WEEKS?!" I exclaimed, my anger growing. "What about without a courtesy car?" This wasn't an option, but I thought I'd ask nonethless.

"We can do it this Friday." The reply was again, slimy. I felt like I was talking to a perverts hotline.

Friday wasn't good for me, as I have visitors coming up on Wednesday and leaving Friday, so the next best option was to book for two weeks, and tolrate the constant flashing of the brake pad warning light for a little longer.

I was put on hold.

1 minute passed.
2 minutes.
3...
4...
At minute eight, I hung up, and thought to myself... There has got to be a better way of doing this!

I drove the the bottom of town, where I knew of lots of garage work due to the high density of boy racers in Leamington. The first garage I saw looked professional enough, and as I walked in I was greeted by a smily chap called Pete. It turns out he owned the place, and later showed me his SL500 with 20 inch rims. Nice. :)

"We work at £30 an hour including VAT here, so it'll be about £90 altogether."

Great, I though, but I cringed as he opened the diary to see when this cheap work could be done.

"And if you leave it with us now, we'll have it back to you at 5."

I was shocked.

I went about my daily business without a courtesy car for the rest of the day, and sure enough, 5 O'Clock rolled around and my car rolled off the ramps, new brakes and all. As I parted with less than a third of the money I would have spent at Mercedes, two weeks down the line, I got back into my car smiling, drove off, and then broke to test out this potential miracle that had befallen me. What a great feel it was. No ABS kicking in because the pads were so worn, the braking was smooth and precise. I know I'd have to bed them in, but for now, I was over the moon.

Just to refresh.

Mercedes: £330. 2 weeks to book.
Pete Scale: £90. 2 minutes to book.

I certainly won't be going to Mercedes any more if work on my car is needed.
 
I think you owe that guy at Mercedes a pint. He did you a favour there :D
 
Nice write up, but you were surprised at this outcome?

Just as well you didn't let the car go in to MB. They might have charged you for the removal of some strange light bulbs they found lodged under your car!
 
Now you should drive to the Merc dealer, tell them the story and show them your new brakes.

Then say "why can't you be as good as them?".

Nice and in-their-face ;).
 
wallingd said:
Now you should drive to the Merc dealer, tell them the story and show them your new brakes.

Then say "why can't you be as good as them?".

Nice and in-their-face ;).


They'll tell you their genuine MB ones are better and laugh smugly...best not.

My car only has 2 MB stamps in the whole service book.
 
Scandalous :eek: just goes to show the extortionate rate large established dealerships are willing to charge to fund their image and glass palace-like showrooms, i asked for a quote on a main service from a dealer and got quoted the best part of £400 of which £280 was labour, so in reality a £120 job which is still an over-rated price for a couple of filters and fluids. my man on the inside charged £200 for the same main service and same day return.
 
Stealerships are always busy, I have to book 4 weeks in advance to get a courtesy car. If you always assume that then it's not so bad.
 
One company is so busy as to need booking well in advance.
The other has so little work they can start immediately.

mmm...
 
I have noticed that with the stealers, thet can normally fit you in quite quickly, but if you need a car you have to wait for them to be available. Do you think that if the labour costs were more reasonable, then they would have more work ? :bannana:
 
Glad you got it sorted at a reasonable price in the end.Ive never used a dealer for anything other than spare parts,So I can't comment on service.All my work gets done at my indi garage thank goodness.I'd hate to see what the price would have been for you at the dealers if you also asked them to supply all the parts as well. :eek: .I reckon best part of £600?
 
nickmann said:
One company is so busy as to need booking well in advance.
The other has so little work they can start immediately.

mmm...

Dealers can often squeze a simple job in at short notice, just like the local garage did.
He's probably busy as hell but just put a less urgent job back. It happens everywhere.
 
Iyse said:
After getting home from a 9am lecture, I bring everything I need outside, chock the backs, jack and stand the front, off with the wheels and I try to locate the first nut on my way to removing the calipers. Once the search is over, out comes the manual torque wrench and I give it a good yank... Nothing. Once again, with a bit more force. Still nothing. After 20 minutes of desperately trying to get this nut off, I decide to give up, as electronic wrenches are probably better suited for this job.

Defeated, I call Mercedes of Coventry (which I always hate doing), go through to service and ask for my car to be booked in. Now, as I live quite a while away from Coventry, I naturally ask for a courtesy car, and as a Mercedes owner, one would expect nothing less. The guy I was speaking to obviously wasn't Enlglish, and had a very slimy way of speaking, almost as if he was patronising me without putting in the effort to do so. After 5 minutes of silence from the other end as he put my details in for the job to be done, I started to get a little annoyed.

Isye
Why were you using a torque wrench to undo the bolts, it's only for tightening?

Please don't "dis" people for their accent or the way they speak. I am as English as anyone here but don't like to hear comments about peoples accents.
I can be as un PC as anyone, and probably more than most, but would never comment on an accent.
 
nickmann said:
One company is so busy as to need booking well in advance.
The other has so little work they can start immediately.

mmm...

It's fair enough to make certain assumptions here. However, my view is that some indies are just more willing to do the work. At the stealership, they seem to clock off pretty promptly, whereas my local guy works crazy hours to fit everyone in at short notice.

However, the main reason that I prefer not to go to a stealership is because to them my car is just another Merc. It's easier to build a relationship with an indy; therefore you can trust them to take pride when they work on your car.

For the record, I am judging stealerships based on just two (Brunswick of Croydon and its replacement on Purley Way, Croydon). No doubt, some will be better than others.
 
Last edited:
nigel cross said:
I have noticed that with the stealers, thet can normally fit you in quite quickly, but if you need a car you have to wait for them to be available. Do you think that if the labour costs were more reasonable, then they would have more work ? :bannana:
That's a standard business dilema – make a high profit margin on limited business, or drop your margin and hope business increases so ultimately your overall profit increases.
The main dealer may well be space / service bay /mechanic limited (apparently it’s very difficult to get mechanics) and could well be maxxed out, so why drop the price?

I strongly believe that there aren’t enough Mercedes dealers – for the range of cars they sell, and bearing in mind that they’re trying in increase volumes, there needs to be much more ‘authorised’ choice available for customers.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom