Why would you pay and then argue?
After they way they have behaved do you seriously think they would pay up? They WANT you to pay.
On the basis that they might have taken payment for goods/services not as agreed.
They told me the £500 I need to pay is on the basis of MB charging 6 hours labour for diagnostics and that they had a £1500 bill to pay before the headlight was ordered/fitted, which was going to cost an extra £1000+, hence them asking me to contribute. This £500 apparently amounted to approximately half of the headlight cost and the further 3 hours labour for fitting the headlight - 9 hours in total, which I don’t believe is true.
I spoke to a little birdie at the dealer who has very kindly informed me only 3 hours labour was charged in total for everything (and at a greatly discounted rate) which included the previously carried out diagnostic work and that they fitted the headlight at no extra charge - to be included in those 3 hours already billed for. I can actually prove this too...
In fact the total invoice for everything - the service which they’re supposed to have been paying for, the new headlight itself, labour, previous diagnostic/coding work and programming the new headlight was for less than they have told me the headlight and labour to fit it was going to cost.
I’ll mention it to them and see what they have to say, not too worried in all honesty but I might ask my credit card company what they suggest if I’ve been charged an extra £500 over what was originally agreed on this basis. Also the deposit I’ve already paid was taken specifically for the car at the original purchase price too, not the increased amount they’re asking me for, which also happens to be exactly £500.
Likewise I have no hesitation in speaking to the guy who originally leaned on the dealer principal to make contact with me a few weeks back, to see if they would like to help. Failing that I’m happy to explain to them that it could affect their reputation if people know the truth about how they operate - not that I intend to do that but it could stir them into action - after all if they’ve done nothing wrong they’d not have anything to worry about...
I’ve already mentally written the £500 off anyway, but as I’ve said before I want to pay for and collect the car first so it’s actually mine before causing any fuss. Worst case I don’t get anywhere and just chalk that £500 up against the cost of the service they’ve paid for, and just swallow the 5 week plus delay for collection.
Best case I get to keep my £500 - to me a few minutes speaking to them or my CC company (or a message to the main group contact) is worth it, I don’t generally earn £500 that quickly.
They also promised a full tank of fuel, hope they’ve remembered that!
In view of the way they’ve handled everything I don’t think I need to maintain a particularly good relationship with them. It would be unlikely for me to want to visit them ever again.