• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

Which car to do anything and everything?

Bobby Dazzler

MB Master
SUPPORTER
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
29,373
Location
Mittel England
Car
Smart ForFour AMG Black Series Night Edition Premium Plus 125 Powered by Brabus
Of all of the cars you’ve owned, which ONE would you choose if you could only have one car to do anything and everything you would ever need a car to do?

Or said another way, which car have you owned which proved to be the one which performed best across the broadest range of purposes, activities or tasks?

It can be any car, from any manufacturer, at any time in history, but it can only be one car, and a car you’ve personally owned. Don’t forget to explain why too.
 
This would usually be a tricky one for me, but driving it in some truly awful weather with widespread flooding, it dawned on me that it’s the most versatile car I’ve ever had.

It’s an unpopular car, it’s both an SUV and an AMG. Many people don’t like SUVs, and often SUV owners and AMG owners agree that the two shouldn’t be combined.

It’s a 2007 W164 ML 63 AMG with the M156 naturally aspirated 6.2 litre V8 engine wihich was first our family car, later my commuting car, and now my winter car.

full


We’ve owned it forever and have covered 130,000 miles in it. It’s the only 15 year old car my main dealer has seen which has been fully serviced on time, every time.

It’s big. It can swallow four adults and luggage for a three week road trip with ease, with space for the dog (properly harnessed) or fifth adult if required.

It’s comfortable. It can cover 1,000 miles in a day without batting an eyelid, and driver and passengers hop out feeling almost as fresh as they did when they set off.

It handles. It’s not a sports car - far from it - but its handling is neat and predictable, cruising on the autobahn or attacking a B road. The ride is remarkably good too.

It shifts. It might be big and blunt but my goodness it goes well. Don’t believe the suggestions that a high revving V8 doesn’t work in an SUV body. It does. Perfectly.

It hustles. On a B road blast, a combination of raw pace and superb visibility means that a sportscar needs to be fast and driven irresponsibly to cover ground more quickly.

It’s charismatic. It has real character. Perhaps imperfectly perfect. Stood next to much more desirable metal it’s the car which attracts the most positive comments.

It screams. Whilst slightly muted compared to other models, it offers a softer edge to the M156’s remarkable vocal range from deep rumble to roar and on to a scream.

It tows. This is where the qualities become rare. Cars that can do all of the above can’t tow, either legally can’t or straight forward can’t. This one can, 3.5 tonnes in fact.

It wades. Also rare. With 4matic (4WD), winter tyres and airmatic suspension set high it will wade through deep water and plough deep snow. It goes anywhere.

full


Sounds too good to be true and must have some flaws, and it does, but they’re both expected and easy to overlook. Those flaws are part of the car’s charisma

It’s heavy. You can’t deny it. It’s a big car and therefore expected, but it hides it well, very well. It’s fast, rides and handles sweetly, and tyres last a very long time.

It’s thirsty. But again it’s expected, and not that much more thirsty than other 63 AMG models. What it costs in fuel is more than offset in the complete lack of depreciation.

There are many memories, which don’t make it a better car to do anything and everything, but they do make it even more special to us. A truly great car.

A three week European tour with my family, ending with our first trip to the AMG engine factory in Affalterbach. Some of the staff even came out to look at it!

Driving through the night from the Italian Lakes to the Midlands, via the Mont Blanc tunnel, and in heavy driving sleet and snow, making our Eurostar just in time.

Driving a W204 C 63 owner to despair - between roundabouts on an NSL dual carriageway - both four up, he was with his mates - and they found it highly amusing.

Chasing a McLaren 675 LT across country. One of my favourite cars, so watching one make progress at close range on a crisp winter evening was special. And fun.

Driving around Donnington Park circuit splitting a Maserati MC12 and a Ferrari Enzo, all accelerating hard out of the Melbourne Hairpin and Goddards.

full
 
Last edited:
SEAT Alhambra...
Very comfortable, versatile, 7 seater. Massive load carrying capacity. Drove faultlessly for 120k miles (had it from new) and only need one set of pads and disc in that time. Coped with deep snow and floods and the a/c managed to keep the five of us cool in the hottest summers and the separate rear heater was great in the winter. The heated windscreen I still miss to this day.
 
Last edited:
SEAT Alhambra...
Very comfortable, versatile, 7 seater. Massive load carrying capacity. Drove faultlessly for 120k miles (had it free new) and only need one set of pads and disc in that time. Coped with deep snow and floods and the a/c managed to keep the five of us cool in the hottest summers and the separate rear heater was great in the winter. The heated windscreen I still miss to this day.
Was that the generation which was jointly engineered as the Ford Galaxy and Volkswagen Sharan? I only ever drove the Galaxy but I really enjoyed it, it was a great car possibly my favourite of all MPVs. Maybe the Space Cruiser had the edge based on quirkiness and rarity.
 
Kia Sorento XT. Big, reliable, comfortable, economical, go almost anywhere with low range.
I know a few people who’ve owned a Sorento and all of them love them - especially the first generation. They’re very popular with caravanners.
 
I have a w164 ML with the AMG body and wheels, but the 3.0 v6 diesel engine. I’ve owned it from new, 17 years now. It has a Brabus tuning box and goes quite well, but delivers over 30mpg, which I can live with. I’ve had a lot of great trips, including many drives to the Algarve via the ferry from Plymouth and latterly Portsmouth to Santander. A point of note, the Brittany Ferries Pont Aven is the choice vessel for that trip. I used to travel out with my wife and kids, and my wife’s parents would fly out for the last couple of weeks. Usually granny and my wife and kids would fly back, and my FIL and I would have a boys road trip on the way home. They were great times, but the best was when that Icelandic volcano fluffed up the airlines. We ended up six-up in the ML with ALL the luggage. My youngest was a babe in arms, and he travelled as such with my wife, tethered in a baby harness to her body and seatbelt. Desperate measures, but desperate times. The wagon was loaded to the absolute limit, but performed admirably. We had a cabin for 5 reserved on the boat and a cot for the baby was added by the crew with no problem. The sight as we drew into Santander was like something from War Of The Worlds. Literally miles of queuing people trying to get a place on that boat, suitcases dragged behind them. I’ve never seen anything like it. The next day a Navy boat arrived to take more brits home apparently. My family still wax on at any opportunity about that road trip. Without a doubt the best I’ve ever had.
 
I have a w164 ML with the AMG body and wheels, but the 3.0 v6 diesel engine. I’ve owned it from new, 17 years now. It has a Brabus tuning box and goes quite well, but delivers over 30mpg, which I can live with. I’ve had a lot of great trips, including many drives to the Algarve via the ferry from Plymouth and latterly Portsmouth to Santander. A point of note, the Brittany Ferries Pont Aven is the choice vessel for that trip. I used to travel out with my wife and kids, and my wife’s parents would fly out for the last couple of weeks. Usually granny and my wife and kids would fly back, and my FIL and I would have a boys road trip on the way home. They were great times, but the best was when that Icelandic volcano fluffed up the airlines. We ended up six-up in the ML with ALL the luggage. My youngest was a babe in arms, and he travelled as such with my wife, tethered in a baby harness to her body and seatbelt. Desperate measures, but desperate times. The wagon was loaded to the absolute limit, but performed admirably. We had a cabin for 5 reserved on the boat and a cot for the baby was added by the crew with no problem. The sight as we drew into Santander was like something from War Of The Worlds. Literally miles of queuing people trying to get a place on that boat, suitcases dragged behind them. I’ve never seen anything like it. The next day a Navy boat arrived to take more brits home apparently. My family still wax on at any opportunity about that road trip. Without a doubt the best I’ve ever had.
My goodness. That trip sounds like a great adventure with the comfort of hindsight. Strange you mentione War of the Worlds as that’s just the kind of mental image I pictured. A great car I’m for that scenario.

Coincidentally, if we ever have to evacuate War of the Worlds style, then it will be the W164 keys that I reach for first. There might even be ready packed crates which drop perfectly into position too 👀
 
Was that the generation which was jointly engineered as the Ford Galaxy and Volkswagen Sharan? I only ever drove the Galaxy but I really enjoyed it, it was a great car possibly my favourite of all MPVs. Maybe the Space Cruiser had the edge based on quirkiness and rarity.
Yes that's the one. What made me smile was when I looked underneath the car there were numerous Audi labels hanging off the suspension parts!
Another favourite was the thermostatically controlled seat heaters, set your desired temp and it stayed the same throughout the journey. Fold down tables and rotating captains chairs. Great car.
 
My old WJ shape Grand Cherokee...the last one with solid axles front and rear so the last one with PROPER off road ability. It had the ML 270 CDI 5 pot.. I bought it to put prams and stuff in when my son was born as it could carry tons of stuff....useful when taking a newborn on holiday. Ended up lifting it and using it off road pretty seriously. Don't get me wrong I don't like SUVs and it, like most SUVs handled like a pig on stilts.....but I bought it to do a job...and it did that job....until it dropped a valve on a cold start at about 150,000 miles and took the engine with it. Was too old to bother fixing so it was exported to Poland for spares! Would I have another?.....no!
 
We had one in the company....it was driving fine when we sold it at about 330,000 miles....lots of which it was towing. The next gen monocoque bodied ones were rubbish.
 
My old WJ shape Grand Cherokee...the last one with solid axles front and rear so the last one with PROPER off road ability. It had the ML 270 CDI 5 pot.. I bought it to put prams and stuff in when my son was born as it could carry tons of stuff....useful when taking a newborn on holiday. Ended up lifting it and using it off road pretty seriously. Don't get me wrong I don't like SUVs and it, like most SUVs handled like a pig on stilts.....but I bought it to do a job...and it did that job....until it dropped a valve on a cold start at about 150,000 miles and took the engine with it. Was too old to bother fixing so it was exported to Poland for spares! Would I have another?.....no!
:ttiuwp
 
I'm split between my Toyota Amazon and my E39 530d.

The Amazon would do anything and go anywhere you asked of it, it brought comfort and civility to environments that would otherwise have been inhospitable, drive all day (and all night)....just not with any real turn of speed!
L5QChowh.jpg


The E39 also did the comfort and civility, but traded go-anywhere do-anything for proper high-speed ground covering endurance. (1000 miles to northern Italy sub 13hrs).
hBGaqCSh.jpg
 
Good topic!

Sadly, as a young (ish) dad, a petrol 2006 MK2 Vauxhall Zafira 2.2 'design' with the twin glass roofs and a sport button was nirvana.

The 7 seats took many kids to ours and others parties, days out, swallowed luggage for Centre PARC's, had tons is space, a bit of pace and for the time, looked good.
The top spec petrol Xtrail we have now is better, but won't create the memories the Zaffy did.

A close second was my first Mercedes a venerable C class coupe. A diesel yes but with a sequential gearbox (yes I had one of those) half decent poke and got me into the brand.
I miss slamming it through the gears like a rally car....

The E400 coupe I have now is much better all round, but a soft spot for the old coupe remains for what it did (include teaching me never to take a RWD car out in the snow on summer tyres - I crashed at the second corner from my house.....)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom