Another engine Oil question, sorry...

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
I shouldn't have asked, honestly. Got the answer but also bonus material, fml
 
Remember when Kwick fit was replacing the air in you tyres with hydrogen or something like that, i always take my airship there to check the pressure.
 
Boyband said:
Hi , before I retired the company I worked for purchased a fleet of diesel VW s

I regiously used the correct oil that cost £15.00 lt.

Most of the lads purchased poor quality oil and one went to Woolies and purchased any thing that was cheap.

Engine fell out of the car !

VW would not provide any warranty work on the car and they cannot be blamed for that action.
Click to expand...

Did the employees change the oil on company cars themselves? Who carried-out the scheduled servicing?
 
merc estate said:
Remember when Kwick fit was replacing the air in you tyres with hydrogen or something like that, i always take my airship there to check the pressure.
Click to expand...
It's nitrogen you refer to, and there's a good reason for doing that in competition cars, but for road cars it's just a gimmick.
 
Gazwould said:
The VW 504.00 507.00 would more than do the job and is higher than your MB spec AMG requirement , real synthetics oil basestocks PAO and Esters are as good as it gets also with a high additive package concentration .
Click to expand...

According to the quote from Blackstone Labs that you provided earlier, there will be little noticeable difference in engine wear by using a 'better' oil than the manufacturer's recommended spec?
 
markjay said:
Did the employees change the oil on company cars themselves? Who carried-out the scheduled servicing?
Click to expand...
Sounds like the drivers had to pay for the oil and diy service their own company cars.
I’m surprised VW didn’t provide a decent warranty though, Woolworths oil is made by Shell.
 
geoffus said:
Sounds like the drivers had to pay for the oil and diy service their own company cars.
Click to expand...
Sounds very odd to me. I'm yet to meet an employer that doesn't consider company provided vehicles as a valuable asset that needs to be properly maintained.

FWIW, I ran several VW TDI PD-engined company cars in the late 1990's / early 2000's that covered the period when VW introduced the extended service interval - but only if Long Life oil was used. Without exception, the lease company demanded annual servicing using the regular oil, not the extended service interval.
 
geoffus said:
Sounds like the drivers had to pay for the oil and diy service their own company cars.
I’m surprised VW didn’t provide a decent warranty though, Woolworths oil is made by Shell.
Click to expand...

So what happens when a warranty claim is rejected because the driver used the wrong oil? The company makes the driver pay for the new engine?
 
st13phil said:
Sounds very odd to me. I'm yet to meet an employer that doesn't consider company provided vehicles as a valuable asset that needs to be properly maintained.

FWIW, I ran several VW TDI PD-engined company cars in the late 1990's / early 2000's that covered the period when VW introduced the extended service interval - but only if Long Life oil was used. Without exception, the lease company demanded annual servicing using the regular oil, not the extended service interval.
Click to expand...
You can't blame the lease company, I imagine those company cars clocked up a great deal of miles in a year, a friend of mine would do 30,000 miles on his work travels.
 
st13phil said:
FWIW, I ran several VW TDI PD-engined company cars in the late 1990's / early 2000's that covered the period when VW introduced the extended service interval - but only if Long Life oil was used. Without exception, the lease company demanded annual servicing using the regular oil, not the extended service interval.
Click to expand...


The crack is to use the LongLife oil annually .
 
Gazwould said:
The crack is to use the LongLife oil annually .
Click to expand...
I dare say that works well, but I knew the guy who bought one of my ex-lease cars when I handed it back with just under 100k on the odo who then ran it for a further 230k miles just using the regular standard oil with the regular oil change interval. The woman t-boning it at a junction did for it in the end, not any engine issue.

As an aside, the PD technology had (and still has) some advantages over common rail. The only reason it was eventually dropped was cost. I have it on good authority that Bosch lost money on every single PD fuel system, but were tied to contract with VW.
 
Boyband said:
Hi , sorry but I did not make it clear they waited until the check engine oil light came on.
Click to expand...

OK, but my question is why did the drivers (employees) buy engine oil for the company cars they were driving? I would have expected the oil changes to be done by a garage, who would also supply the oil for the service. These are fleet cars, not privately-owned vehicles - no?

EDIT - or are you saying that the cars were never serviced, and consumed a lot of oil, so the drivers would walk into the local Woolworths and add a (say) 1L bottle of engine oil from time to time? Still sounds like an odd scenario...?
 
markjay said:
OK, but my question is why did the drivers (employees) buy engine oil for the company cars they were driving? I would have expected the oil changes to be done by a garage, who would also supply the oil for the service. These are fleet cars, not privately-owned vehicles - no?

EDIT - or are you saying that the cars were never serviced, and consumed a lot of oil, so the drivers would walk into the local Woolworths and add a (say) 1L bottle of engine oil from time to time? Still sounds like an odd scenario...?
Click to expand...
It almost sounds a made up story to me, a fleet of new company cars on DiY servicing and all damaged engines except his. Or am I just a bit sceptical.
Anyway I’m just off to feed my baby unicorn.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)

Similar threads

L
Noise after oil and filter change
Replies
3
Views
809
Tonygw
T
J
250 cdi 5w40 oil 2013 saloon
Replies
7
Views
914
Jazz29
J
A
Replacing Engine oil dipstick for W204
Replies
1
Views
660
Flyinspanner
Flyinspanner
M
Engine oil what the difference SAE 5w-30 MB229.51 ?
Replies
13
Views
4K
merc estate
M
B
Would somebody ever deliberately overfill an M271 with oil?
Replies
16
Views
2K
Petrol Pete
Petrol Pete
Back
Top Bottom