The E is in a different class (excuse the pun). I tried 4 205 Cs and just couldn't get excited about them at all, then test drove one E and, even though it is the 2015 model, rather than the current one, it is so much more accomplisthed I didn't hesitate. Picked it up a week ago and not a smidge of a regret in going for the boxier older E as opposed to the newer curvier C. Having said that, try both and go with what floats your own boat!