• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

Rad blind experiment

i've thought about blocking up the gaps i have on my bumper under the bonnet to reduce drag...

If you are chatting about your C230K, blocking the holes in the bumper just below the numberplatewill reduce airflow to your intercooler. You would get a reduction in power as a result.... I would imagine you wouldnt want that:devil:

230k
 
If it worked well 80 years ago on this...

33_Rolls-Rocye_20-25_DV_05_Amelia_06.jpg


(thermostaticallly controlled radiator shutters)

and was indispensible 50 years ago on this...

a30radiatorblind.jpg


then I'm sure this handcrafted effort will work just as well here...

Radblind.jpg


;)
 
I agree that the cooling intakes are the same across the range but does anyone know if the radiators are the same size?

Possibly not, but the one on this car is full size but it would appear it doesn't need to be as they never get too hot even without a fan.

If the radiators are different sizes all that would mean is that the greater amount of wasted heat will make the engine bay hotter and would require more airflow, but that same amount of airflow isn't required for the lesser wasting engines but isn't altered as manufactured.

I've just got back from a motorway drive and can say the car is definitely more stable when passing lorries, you just don't notice them at all now whereas they would push the car around a bit with their wake.

One observation is that the EGT temperatures tend to rise a little when stationary after driving then fall back to normal. This is probably due to radiated heat keeping the exhaust manifold warmer for a while.
The water temperature is no warmer than normal.
 
Diesel, i'm guessing your soul-purpose of doing this is to reduce drag, and to be honest with you, i've thought about blocking up the gaps i have on my bumper under the bonnet to reduce drag... does the 210 have considerably large gaps on the bumper? or would this make no difference?

As 230k says, don't block the under grille because of the intercooler, but also because that's in a very high pressure, stagnant air area so works very well without creating much drag. The bonnet grille is in an area of faster moving airstream and causes more drag.

You could always try it but beware if you drive your car hard it will require lots of cooling air as it has to dissipate about 250kw of heat, mines only ever going to need about 170kw due to higher thermal efficiency.
 
me and my father are blocking same way as you doo, every winter, what i got from it ? only about 15% faster engine warm up=some economy :D but still even with cover engine is cooling down if i drive 120km/h @3000rpm :D to 70C
 
still even with cover engine is cooling down if i drive 120km/h @3000rpm :D to 70C

OM605 / 606 engines tend to run at about 75c even with an 80c thermostat fitted.

I suspect what happens is that with the blind fitted the thermostat opens up more so allows more water to flow round the radiator, hence still keeps cool.
In one respect this is a good thing as it reduces the pumping effort due to a closed thermostat.

How much of the rad is blocked off and have you ensured the engine air intake is still exposed to fresh air.
 
then I'm sure this handcrafted effort will work just as well here...
;)

Hmm, not quite sure how to take that Del, but for experimenting I just used what came to hand. I needed the barrel to use as a storage box so just used the side I cut off for this. It fits tight up against the back of the grille so seals pretty well in that area.

Anyway...I like free mods...all the more satisfying when they work..

I've got more barrels, do you want a piece..?? :D
 
ive followed your lead DM and blanked off, with aluminium foil, half of both grills on this astra i'm now driving, there isn't a temperature gauge on the instruments and ive no idea what temp the engine's been running at but the heater is now much better, so its stopping like that until the weather improves, cheers
 
It shouldnt make much difference to how quickly the car warms up because the thermostat if closed shouldnt allow significant flow through the radiator

I know most modern cars are over-cooled but that shouldnt make a difference if the thermostat is working correctly , I fitted a massive alloy radiator to my Skyline last summer , made no difference to the running temp but when pushing the car hard the temperature remains more stable and comes down faster

There should be no need for a blind on an modern motor car, not in the UK anyway sounds like someone has been watching Ice Road truckers where the purpose of the blinds is to INCREASE underbonnet temps to prevent damage to electrics.

Cue the "I've fitted a starting handle to my car" and "Where can i buy wire spoked wheels for my E class " threads ;):):)
 
Quick google reveals e300td 97 on rad core size 640x490x40 same core size as my 430, site didnt list e55 and i was to lazy to look any further:D .

I remember running no viscous fan on my tdi discos, std basic car was okay but next disco with air con rad cooling was border line, next one (3rd) was an auto and once viscous removed started to overheat and also suffered from heat soak after a motorway run quite badly especially in the summer and the kenlowe fan couldnt cut the mustard.

Last one td5 famous for head gasket failures (plastic head dowels:eek: ) i alway ran the std set u,p but with a larger intercooler the viscous fan cut in quite a bit more frequently so obviously air flow was more restricted.



Lynall
 
There should be no need for a blind on an modern motor car, not in the UK anyway sounds like someone has been watching Ice Road truckers

How fast are those lorries going then...not fast enough for aerodynamics to have any effect...are they?

As far as no car requiring blinds, why do some manufacturers fit them then...they could save a few pounds if only they listen to maddog...you need to contact them, they need your input..

A low heat output car does benefit from a blind as heat is lost from the engine block, not just the radiator, but if you actually read the post you'll see that not why it's been fitted...the test is to ensure it doesn't overheat, not to assist warming.
 
Quick google reveals e300td 97 on rad core size 640x490x40 same core size as my 430, site didnt list e55 and i was to lazy to look any further:D .

Thanks Lynall.

The 430 must be losing about 250kw or more of heat which is way more than the 300TD can generate, so reducing it's working area should still leave a considerable reserve.

Obviously the grille is designed for the maximum loss required, which is also way too large for this application.
 
There should be no need for a blind on an modern motor car, not in the UK anyway sounds like someone has been watching Ice Road truckers where the purpose of the blinds is to INCREASE underbonnet temps to prevent damage to electrics.

Cue the "I've fitted a starting handle to my car" and "Where can i buy wire spoked wheels for my E class " threads ;):):)


Dieselman is doing this to a great extent to gauge the aerodynamic effect and whether the car will slip through the air more easily and give more economy, and be quieter etc etc.

I guess he was prompted by the recent articles re the latest Merc bluetec models appearing on the market that give better economy via the use of various aids such as this one and numerous others.

I have considered these myself and the potential for retrofitting various aids to economy, and there are plenty of things we can do.
 
In the same way that there is a tension between drag and downforce on racing cars - often mentioned in F1 commentary - there is a similar tension between drag and cooling, both on racing cars and on road cars.

Creating downforce by definition creates drag. Similarly cooling the engine by definition creates drag, whether that be via the cooling system or reduction of underbonnet temperatures.

Does this not mean your underbonnet air temperature will rise---not the engine you understand since its got a direct coupled means of cooling via the "part rad"--- but the air space and with it all those sensitive little sensors/ECU'S which don't like it hot??? Surely a better solution would be to arrange additional "exits" via louvres under the wings or on the bonnet assuming they didn't screw with the aerodynamics??

Underbonnet temperatures may rise slightly, but hot air is drawn out of the engine bay from the low pressure areas, rather than pushed out from high pressure areas. If air is able to exit, then it will draw cool air in through the reduced aperature.

Something I noticed the other day on the motorway when it was wet, was that there seems to be more air passing over the bonnet, enough for the emblem to make turbulance and spray water droplets backwards.

The blind will create a larger stagnant volume which, is likely to spread up rather than down, and will deflect a little more air over the bonnet than may otherwise be the case.

I wouldn't expect the turbulence to increase significantly though, maybe even reduce. The air passing over the bonnet wouldn't accelerate more than usual, and the greater stagnation would likely smooth the radius and therefore the path of air passing over the bonnet. It would be marginal though.

Might just be more noticeable given the damp/wet conditions of late. ;)

I love driving in the rain, because it opens up a whole new dimension is seeing your car work. You can see things you otherwise wouldn't see - marvel at the airflow around the A-pillar for example.

As 230k says, don't block the under grille because of the intercooler, but also because that's in a very high pressure, stagnant air area so works very well without creating much drag. The bonnet grille is in an area of faster moving airstream and causes more drag.

Stagnant air at the intake maximises the potential difference between inlet and outlet, and therefore maximises air flow through the engine bay. The stagnant air isn't what's causing the drag though.

The benefits here will come from reducing drag 'inside' the car, rather than 'outside' the car. Drag caused by air passing through the radiator is considerable, and generally significant around the other gubbins found in the engine bay.
 
I had some airflow diagrams of the W210 estate somewhere. I'll see if I can dig them out - I suspect they went to the tip when I cleared out the garage though. :(
 
What have you done DM??!! I appear to be reigniting old flames of interest that I thought had long since been extinguished!!

Whilst it appears to be a HGV powertrain and chassis, there's an interesting CFD sim here, showing airflows related to underbonnet cooling:
http://www.mira.co.uk/Services/Consultancy-Thermal.htm

A little small, and lacking detail, but it's the right car!! :D

58.gif


More detail, but a W204 this time - notice that the high pressure area is closer to the lower intake more than the upper grille.

2008-mercedes-c-class-42_800x0w.jpg
 
Dieselman

While out for a walk this morning i noticed a few cars getting the same treatment.

This one has adjustable flaps.
Image000_2.jpg




And this one has been given a whole new look.
Image001_2.jpg


Couldnt resist :D :D :D

Dieselman, don't rise to it!!:p :p

I would be really interested to hear if it improves fuel consumption.

230k
 
Last edited:
Tis true most cars here ARE over cooled as standard because its cheaper for a manufacturer to fit the same rad across europe (cold at the top, hot at the bootom) than it is to have to fit bigger or smaller ones. I do lots of engine swops and us lot tend to work on how much BHP a specific rad will cool in this climate, as a general rule its twice as much as the biggest engine fitted to that model, a sierra cossie rad will cool 500bhp for instance, so running the standard 200bhp motor, you could block off over 50% of it and still keep the engine healthy. My 200bhp Cortina had a rad designed for a 140bhp engine in it as it was the biggest one i could get in with cutting metal and it kept it cool even blatting it round a track in the summer, my old W115 Merc rust bucket had nearly all the lil fins missing off the rad but it still kept it cool all last summer, even in traffic, My coupe is having trouble getting up to temp in the snow, the thermostat is working but the temp guage still wont reach its normal postion, even after a 60 mile run, so i've been wahcking the cardboard on the rad during this snowy weather to get that legendary shoe burning power back into my heater.
 
And this one has been given a whole new look.
Image001_2.jpg


Dieselman, don't rise to it!!:p :p

I would be really interested to hear if it improves fuel consumption.

230k

Ohh, why not...nice subtle mod...and the bonnet bra could be good for stopping chips...and look at that aerodynamic wiper delete mod..looks just like a Merc now.. :D

fuel economy...

Just been to fill up..!

At the halfway point of the tank it had covered 370 miles, so was short of my record 405....then I fitted the blind and went for a few miles thrashing to observe temperatures..
Since then It's been normal mixed driving, but I'm sure it's more stable on the motorway.

Ok.
When I achieved 405 to half a tank I got 696 to the tank. There was a bit left but it was pretty empty, so today I filled at 701 miles..:bannana:

That's a gain of 35miles in under half a tank, including performance testing the mod..

I'll keep a tally and see how it goes.
 
Last edited:
What have you done DM??!! I appear to be reigniting old flames of interest that I thought had long since been extinguished!!

Whilst it appears to be a HGV powertrain and chassis, there's an interesting CFD sim here, showing airflows related to underbonnet cooling:
http://www.mira.co.uk/Services/Consultancy-Thermal.htm

I've got the 210 pic..had it as my avatar for a while...

Manufacturers have taken their eye off the ball with respect to aerodynamics, but Mercedes have always been pretty good in that respect, most have gone backwards. If you want a car to go fast safely and quietly it needs good aero.

You need to look at the acomodded forum.. Those guys have got it off to a Tee.

http://ecomodder.com/forum/showthre...namic-drag-rolling-resistance-power-6341.html
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom