I went with the Varta F21, as the rumour is that Varta make the Merc batteries for the W212, and they tend to last 10 years if used regularly/looked after.
Whether they are exactly the same as those supplied to Merc vs sold aftermarket, who knows.
Merc batteries come with a 2 year warranty.
But, the Varta silver 'only' come with a 4 year warranty.
The Bosch S5 series come with a 5 year warranty.
The prices for these can be quite up and down over the months, and the various batteries seem to compete with each other on price, so sometimes one battery can be much cheaper one month, then swap round the next.
The screenshot I listed with prices was for Tayna batteries, who are usually competitive.