You misunderstand me; I don't have a 'proper dislike' for 'pro detailers'.
I think the level of importance that yourself and other 'detailers' put on your work is pie in the sky, that's all.
I think the finish on the car paintwork that you do is excellent, and i do genuinely believe that, but to compare it to say a mechanic or a plumber is astonishing.
I've enjoyed the debate, either way.
I get the impression you're into antiques.
Think about this. I am a practical person, I can turn my hand to pretty much anything, to an extent.
Lets say I had an piece of antique furniture that was worth £2000. Lets also say that this piece of furniture is a bit tired after a long life servicing whatever need it was designed to fulfil. If I wanted to get it looking like new I would have two choices.
Do it myself or pay someone with the necessary skills, equipment and experience to do it for me.
So lets say I read something on an internet forum and got out my £25 B&Q sander, a pack of assorted sand papers and set to (it's a table in my head.) I sand off the old layers of varnish, use some finer papers to finish off so it's nice and smooth and then varnish it with a few coats of a varnish from B&Q sanding gently between each coat to make sure it's nice and shiny. I guess I could make it look ok. But I suspect I would massively devalue the table.
My alternative would be to pay a restorer to do whatever it is they do to bring it back to life. I suspect this would cost me a few hundred pounds because the time it takes time to do right and the person doing it has honed his/her skills over a number of years.
In this case I would pay the restorer because it would be done right and would retain the value of the piece, actually, it would probably enhance it.
I bet if you are into antiques you were wincing when I was talking about going to work on it in my garage!!
I value the skill of the restorer and the professional detailer in the same way.
If you don't get detailing don't hire a detailer. But please don't rubbish what they do.