• The Forums are now open to new registrations, adverts are also being de-tuned.

Annual "ease of car theft" report

scotth_uk

MB Enthusiast
Joined
May 16, 2003
Messages
2,570
Location
Sydney
Car
Renault
CARS STILL EASY PICKINGS

Security experts say car makers still have some way to go to make their vehicles safe from thieves.

In trials for WhatCar? magazine, they were able to break into 80% of vehicles within a two-minute limit.


Most models proved easy work, with the Fiat Panda Dynamic opened in just eight seconds.

It took 11 seconds to get into a Kia Picanto SE.

Only a handful of cars defied the efforts of the testers, including two BMWs.

Passing with flying colours were the BMW 525i SE, Lexus RX300 SE-L, Peugeot 407 SE and BMW X3 SE.

The experts were allowed only commonly available tools for the tests and were trying to break into 20 new cars without damaging them.

What Car? said that although the British Crime Survey suggested car crime was 12% down in 2003-04, there are still more than 1.3 million thefts from cars each year.

Editor David Motton said: "Car security is far better than a decade ago but there are still some popular cars on sale with weak locking systems.

"We advise all buyers to consider the results of our security tests before they buy."

Mr Motton also advised car owners to never leave belongings on show to tempt thieves, always lock vehicles and activate the alarm and immobiliser where fitted.

Models Tested:

1 BMW 525i SE - No entry within 2 minutes

2 Lexus RX300 SE-L - No entry within 2 minutes

3 Peugeot 407 SE - No entry within 2 minutes

4 BMW X3 SE - No entry within 2 minutes

5 Skoda Octavia Ambiente - 117 sec

6 Volvo S40 SE - 108 sec

7 Volkswagen Touran S -100 sec

8 Citroen C2 VTR - 75 sec

9 BMW 116i - 69 sec

10 Audi A6 Quattro SE - 64 sec

11 Peugeot 307 CC - 63 sec

12 Renault Scenic Privilege - 53 sec

13 Mini Cooper S Convert - 52 sec

14 Vauxhall Astra Design - 46 sec

15 Subaru Legacy SE - 40 sec

16 Mazda RX-8 - 39 sec

17 Smart Forfour Pulse - 31 sec

18 VW Golf GT - 26 sec

19 Kia Picanto SE - 11 sec

20 Fiat Panda Dynamic - 8 sec
 
If they had bothered to test a Mercedes they'd probably have found that's impossible to get into within 2 mins as well, shares the EIS etc with BMW as it's all bosch stuff!

All these test fall down when a window is broken though, then it's under 10 seconds to get into any car unless it has security film, high quality tinted windows, double-glazing or it's an armoured version :)
 
Shude said:
If they had bothered to test a Mercedes they'd probably have found that's impossible to get into within 2 mins as well, shares the EIS etc with BMW as it's all bosch stuff!


Not quite , a bmw has deadlocks , mercedes doesnt for safety reasons , thus you can open the lock easier.

You can't drive it away tho!
 
Should have included the director's limo that got stolen a few weeks back.
 
scotth_uk said:
Should have included the director's limo that got stolen a few weeks back.
Not fair, they never actually got into it within 2 minutes! That was stolen with a truck, you can steal anything if you have a big enough truck and a crane! ;)
 
Did Jurgen ever get his beloved £500k S Class back? I bet that would be a hot car to sell on. :crazy: It was an S Guard with all the works wasn't it?

S.
 
Steve_Perry said:
Did Jurgen ever get his beloved £500k S Class back? I bet that would be a hot car to sell on. :crazy: It was an S Guard with all the works wasn't it?

S.


Depends who nicked it .. there are just some people you don't shop :)
 
Steve_Perry said:
Did Jurgen ever get his beloved £500k S Class back? I bet that would be a hot car to sell on. :crazy: It was an S Guard with all the works wasn't it?
They could probably fit all the parts to another s-class and scrap the chassis, that way it's *almost* untraceable.
 
Jurgen's car is rumoured to have gone to Russia. It was a fully loaded S Class to Guard level 7/8. Basically only stopped by its own electronics.
 
saorbust said:
Jurgen's car is rumoured to have gone to Russia. It was a fully loaded S Class to Guard level 7/8. Basically only stopped by its own electronics.

Think it was an insurance job ? ;)
 
I can't see the point of the study because it was only about breaking into a car and not driving it away.

Surely the very definition, or wording of the test 'break into' means I can 'break' a window. Okay the BMW has deadlocks, :) but a thief might, just might go in through the broken window!!!!!! It must be me, I must be missing something????


I would be VERY interested in a test whereby the potential thief 'breaks' into the vehicle and manages to drive it away without using the vehicles ignition key. That to me is the only relevant test.

Regards,
John The nit picker
 
he is not alone

the mayor of the town he was in had his nicked 2 weeks earlier...off to USSR with that one as well
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom