Whether it's 700, 550 or just 10 victims is not the point. It's still a national disgrace. Victims were clearly poorly represented, were lied to, and their defence counsels were prevented from getting access to all the relevant documents (which is surely illegal on it's own). The board takes ultimate responsibility and must have known what was going on ("We didn't know" doesn't hack it), no matter what level the scam was being operated at. And yes I do regard it as a scam. Those at the PO involved should be prosecuted for perverting the course of justice and the heads of the CPS who allowed the prosecutions to proceed should be removed. Vennells in particular should be prevented at the very least from holding any directorship or position of trust. JMO obviously but the whole sordid affair is a classic example of what large organizations get up to. And boy have I come up with similar sleaze in such places.
Sorry, but I didn't say it was "the point." I just pointed out that - to be blunt - hysterically exaggerating the issue - doesn't do much towards getting it fixed.
And... as I pointed out later on, if the system was faulty, what happened to the other 10,300 Post Offices over that ten years? They weren't taken to court, but were there claims? Did other Postmasters NOT have a problem, did other Postmasters HAVE a problem but hid it, by subsidising it from their own pockets?
Skimming and fraud is common in post offices, banks and in any cash handling retail business. Both at owner and employee level. Most cases don't reach court - it's not to anyone's benefit to publish or fight a case. Watch the young, and the old, and everyone in between, not checking the cash they receive. Yes, the majority do, but a significant minority don't.
It's ridiculous to say that the Archbishop of Canterbury should be fired because a Churchwarden or Curate skims a few hundred out of the plate down in Cornwall. The responsibility sits much lower down to actually manage the transactions, monitor the numbers, and take action when things appear to be be going wrong.
IT systems like this are rife with imbalances on accounts, in every form of business. It's grist to the mill for junior accountants (aka bookkeepers). Even your local self employed taxi driver knows that the accounts never add up correctly.
Is it a scam that the accounts in your local Coop don't add up? Nope. It's routine retail.
At the market, or in a small bar, on the weekend? Watch out for the staff skimming the takings, and short-changing people who they spot aren't noticing what's going on.