Doodle
MB Enthusiast
Well at the end of the day that is a personal choice. If you defend yourself against a burglar and hurt them then you'll be in court anyway. The salient point is that the court now properly considers the heat of the moment rather than a paper shuffling exercise 6 months after the event. Police are never going to attend such a situation in good time because in almost every case they will be too late so every situation will have extenuating circumstances.
At the very least if you could disable an intruder with pepper spray that would give the police time to arrive and deal with the perpetrator?
If you go at them with a firearm, it's a court appearance without question. However, thanks to the increased consideration you mention, using the poker that sits by the fire/impromptu sporting equipment/large pair of stilsons you left by the radiator after doing the plumbing, it may never get that far.
Recourse to disable/incapacitate without permanent harm (such as your example of pepper spray) seems eminently reasonable to me. As does Trunk Monkey