MOCAŠ
MB Enthusiast
I've heard this a number of times, and while I don't entirely disagree I'm left wondering why the same is not said of the A or B class.
There are a number of justifications for it. In my opinion, the A and B Classes are cars in their own right (particularly the A Class, which originally was developed from scratch on its own independent platform), and they are/were built in Germany - all of which gives these cars credibility within the range, although of course the A and B both have more than their fair share of detractors.
The Sportcoupe/CLC, on the other hand, can be seen as a cynical exercise to wring some extra sales from the C Class platform, and some feel it has a strong sense of style-over-substance about it. Then there's its technical merits; a sporting version of a car would normally be positioned above the car on which it is based, and would be seen as drawing custom to the whole range through reflected glory; yet the Sportcoupe/CLC was defiantly placed below the saloon/estate models (as has been pointed out, no C55/63 versions).
That said, it wouldn't be the first car that had traded on its looks at the expense of its character/performance, but even here it somehow falls between two stools. I've never really felt that the front and back ends of the car have been properly introduced to each other, and when viewed without rose-tinted spectacles, it can be mistaken for a slightly distorted version of any number of euro-hatches - I sometimes see something of the original Citroën Xsara about it, albeit with a Mercedes-Benz front grafted on.
Then there's the build quality. Although the original article in this thread seems harshly worded, there is a feeling about the coupe that it was built down to a price, and one has to conclude that this is simply because it was. I can't speak for the CLC in this respect, but I did spend some time poring over its predecessor while I was waiting at my dealership while my car was being MoT'd one day, and it felt very mainstream. I also found that the panel attached to the back of the driver's seat started to come away as I was getting out of the back seat; not good, especially on a brand new car.
Finally, in those markets where the A and B class are not (yet) offered, it actually is MB's entry level model, whereas that role really ought to fall to the C Class saloon. One of those markets is the US, where it really is seen as the type of car that fathers buy for their teenage daughters (hence my previous "college" comment).